“Survivor 48” recap: A finale filled with tears and triumph

Key Points

• Kyle Fraser won the final immunity challenge and then kept on winning, emerging as the champion of Survivor 48.

• Eva had another breakdown over making fire, but powered through it to make it into the final three.

• The angry looking jury was actually quite nice once they started talking. Even mean-mugging David!

Knock knock…
[Super long awkward pause]
Who’s there?

Me! Who else would be there? Hell, I’ve been ignoring my family to recap this show for over 20 years, so why stop now? Especially right before a season finale. That would make no sense. Almost as little sense as teasing on social media that you are going to reveal the Survivor 50 cast during the Survivor 48 finale and then doing no such thing. (Poor Survivor 49 cast getting no advance CBS social media love.)

But I am here to recap the finale and I am here to say this: So much for honor and integrity! In the end, the Survivor 48 jury rewarded the guy who lied the most — and the most effectively — in the game and then campaigned on his biggest lie right to their faces. When they handed Kyle $1 million, they also, effectively, buried honor and integrity over on Ghost Island next to Erik’s immunity necklace and the Medallion of Power.

But we all know what happens to items buried on Ghost Island… they mature with awesome new powers, only to be unleashed on an unsuspecting future cast! YOU CANNOT STOP HONOR AND INTEGRITY! YOU CAN ONLY HOPE TO CONTAIN IT!

Something else that could not be stopped on Survivor 48? Kyle Fraser. Along with partner in crime Kamilla, he was a part of the three most impressive moves of the game — the blindsides of Thomas, David, and Shauhin. Kyle was so good at deception, he even fooled me! I really liked Kyle when we spoke in Fiji before the game, but my read on him is that he was simply too nice a guy to get his hands dirty enough to win this game. Evidently, his tribe mates felt the same way, and believed every smiling lie he spilled along the way.

He also won the final immunity challenge and had no fear taking on the two people that everyone else in the cast seemed desperate to not sit next to in the end, Joe and Eva. Give Kyle his flowers. He played a great all-around game and is a worthy name to etch into the imaginary Sole Survivor trophy that exists only in my mind. (It’s shaped like a giant torch, btw.)

Related: Jeff Probst previews ‘quirky’ and ‘sweltering’ Survivor 49 (exclusive)

But I also want to give flowers to the two people he beat, Joe and Eva, because this was a true final Tribal Council rarity in that all three finalists gave rock solid day 26 performances. I’m not saying this is the best final three in Survivor history, but I do think it was one of the best all-around final Tribal performances for all three members sitting on those stools. And there were several moments you could feel the momentum shifting back and forth between the players.

Kyle, of course, was great. He made the jury laugh by talking about his unimpressive butt, his humble yet simultaneously braggy final statement that he was “the best average guy you’ll ever meet” totally landed, and his best moment was when he (with a major assist from Kamilla) was able to completely undercut Eva taking credit for the Shauhin vote-off by revealing how he manipulated the other two finalists to make that happen.

Joe started off a bit shaky; you never want to tell a jury that your biggest weakness is caring about people too much — the same people you voted out. But he recovered nicely by highlighting his challenge prowess not just at the advanced reality TV age of 45, but also nine months after reconstructive surgery. (Not that juries care at all about challenge wins, which I have pointed out numerous times.) He also did well in using humor to draw attention to his blue-collar life and contrasting himself against the secret smarty-pants lawyer and PhD candidate next to him: “I’m just a dumb fireman, still.”

He returned to this theme in his final words: “I may not be a lawyer, I may not be a doctor, I’m just a fireman. I spend my life taking care of other people, and for once, I want the opportunity to take care of my kids for the rest of their lives.” That’s a powerful message.

But Eva’s final words were even more powerful. She had already scored points by revealing her Safety Without Power that many did not know about, and then brought it all home with a strong exclamation point.

“We’ve been saying this season that 48 is an unprecedented season. I believe you should select an unprecedented winner. We’ve had lawyers who played the middle before and win. We’ve had challenge threats play a well-rounded game and win. But you have never seen a player like me. I was not afraid to show who I am. I played very black and white, but that is because I am loyal and I wanted to play with who I am. I know that I carried more wood than anyone ever has on Survivor! I made Jeff cry! This unprecedented season should be represented by someone who embodies what this season is. So I believe you should vote for me.”

That’s a great final speech. Survivor juries do want to make a mark with their vote, and Eva appealed to them to be bold with their decision making by setting herself apart from not only the two people sitting next to her, but other Survivor winners from the past. She used humor with the wood comment. She referenced that big softie, Jeff Probst. Was it enough to move people off Kyle? No, but that doesn’t mean it didn’t land.

Related: Jeff Probst reveals scrapped Survivor finale vote delivery scene (exclusive)

As for the jury, you all know I miss the days when people took things super personally and would lash out in crazy ways and say crazy things. Bitter juries weren’t always tons of fun with their votes, but the drama before the votes was truly popcorn-worthy. A little spice would certainly have been nice here.

That said, there was something interesting about the structure of the jury questions. It seemed to me to be something of a Goldilocks final Tribal in that it merged some of the old-school Survivor jury Q&As with some of the new-school discussion format. It wasn’t just a massive free-for-all as some final Tribals have been since the new format was introduced. And jurors appeared to have designated moments for each of their specific questions, like in early seasons. But there was also some brief back and forth when warranted, like when Kamilla jumped in to Kyle’s rescue. I thought it generally worked well. Just could have used a bit more kick… which I guess we were hoping to come from David. That mean-mugging prankster!

Okay, let’s touch on a few other things worth touching on. (Sorry, bad wording.)

The comeback Kamilla

I’ve made my position on advantages in finale competitions clear. I’m not a fan. I just much prefer seeing players battle on an even playing field and find that to be more dramatic. The good news in this case is that Eva’s advantage of being able to place her ball directly in the basket was negligible, seeing as how all the other players seemed to land theirs on their first or second shot. But why do the entire advantage game segment if it wasn’t going to make a difference?

Of course, it wasn’t just the advantage that did not matter. The entire challenge did not matter until you got the puzzle. You longtime readers have heard me say it a million times before — physical sections of a challenge are all window dressing for the only section that actually matters… the puzzle. Ninety percent of the time, if you win the puzzle, you win the challenge, no matter when you get to that final section.

But this is merely an observation, not a complaint! Because I love watching Kamilla twisting her entire body the wrong way in the net. I love Joe’s ball bouncing off the side of a frame and him having to go chase it down over by the camera crew. I love Eva being totally blind because mud is caked all over her eyes. This stuff is all great, even if has no bearing whatsoever on the final result.

And, yes, I, like everybody else, love a good comeback. I don’t know if this was New Kamilla or Old Kamilla who won immunity after stepping into the puzzle domination station, but it was fun to see regardless.

Mitch’s last stand

I suppose now is the point in the recap where I should rattle off a few lame Mailman Mitch jokes. I don’t know, something like…
Mailman Mitch got a special delivery… to the jury house!
Mailman Mitch had the entire package… so he had to go!
The tribe had a Tree Mail for Mailman Mitch, and it read… RETURN TO SENDER!

Honestly, I don’t even really know what that last one means. Look, postal service puns are hard! (Perhaps I should have asked the Hostmaster General for help.) But yeah, it was time for Mitch to go. I know this because every single player told him point blank it was time to go. Didn’t try to hide it. Said it right to his face. This is what happens when there is no Shot in the Dark to play and everyone is in hardcore jury management mode. The show didn’t even bother to put forth a red herring or try to edit around it, instead choosing to lean into it and give Mitch a proper Survivor funeral.

It was nice. It was touching. But it couldn’t help but sap some drama out of the night’s first Tribal Council since everyone knew who was going. BTW, am I crazy for wondering if they should extend the Shot in the Dark through the final five? Probably. There are already too many gimmicks keeping players in the game in the homestretch, but this whole situation reminded me once again that the SITD is the best Survivor twist addition since the hidden immunity idol, precisely because it does force players to blindside each other and lead to more stunned reactions at Tribal Council rather than players knowing they were done before they ever stepped onto to the TC set.

Anyway, Mitch is great. A super fun guy, which you saw on the show. I know some viewers were frustrated when he didn’t join with Mary and Star to take out biggest perceived threat Joe, but my finale interviews with the jury and final five show that Mary was actually a massive threat to win the game, making Mitch’s reluctance to keep her in the game make a lot more sense in retrospect.

Simmotion by the ocean

What a difference a day makes. On day 24, Kamilla was saying she knew Kyle was the biggest obstacle to her winning, but could not go after him and was playing for both of them. “I thought I could separate the logic from the heart and the emotion in this game, and I can’t,” she said.

Well, that’s yesterday’s news! Because now it’s day 25 and the new headline is that Kyle has got to go! And Kamilla tells him exactly that, saying that if she wins immunity, he is going to fire against Joe. What changed? The whiff of a million bucks, most likely. But why tell Kyle that before the immunity contest? Why not hedge your bets so he feels compelled to bring you should he win? (Which he did.) Kamilla is so smart, so the timing of this announcement stumps me.

But speaking of the final immunity challenge, it is none other than the old-school Survivor classic SOS competition where the players have to compete to make the best rescue sign on the beach and then some guy flues overhead, plays a game of eeny-meeny-miney-moe and just randomly picks someone as the winner.

NO! That’s not it! That would be crazy! But you already know what it was. It was the same final immunity challenge that is always run, Simmotion. Okay, not always, but this marks the sixth time the challenge has been run in the past 13 seasons, with all of those except Ghost Island being the final immunity contest. It got a year off for Survivor 46 but has otherwise been used as the last competition in every even numbered season going all the way back to Winners at War.

It’s an amazing challenge, to be sure. Big fan. Love it. It’s just been used… a lot. Which is precisely why I did not select it as the Survivor 50 final contest in the fan voting. Anyway, Kyle indeed did win, making the timing of Kamilla’s announcement more dire since Kyle was now free to not bring her to the end. (I believe in Survivor parlance they call that the “moral go-ahead.”) But that does not mean there would be no drama surrounding Kyle’s decision and the fire-making to follow.

A cast on fire

I get that people were tired of Joe and Eva sitting way too comfortable all season at the top of the Survivor food chain. We want our animals all eating each other out there on the island. That makes for better, more dramatic television. Totally agree. But I don’t get not being completely moved by their connection and what went down earlier this season at the challenge where Eva had to fight through an episode and then, with Joe’s assistance, fight through being emotionally overwhelmed in the aftermath. That was beautiful stuff. What we got during this week’s finale was, in certain aspects, even more interesting and impactful, and it extended beyond just #Joeva.

Kyle announced he was bringing Joe to the end and letting Kamilla and Eva battle it out at fire. So Eva went out to practice, but her inability to start a flame became increasingly frustrating, to the point where she started to lose it. Kyle and Joe could hear the screams in the shelter, so Joe went to investigate. When he saw a crying, shaking Eva, Joe hugged her to help bring her back from the brink. But then he did something else, offering to take her spot in the fire-making competition.

It was an impressive gesture met with an equally impressive response. “No. No. This is my thing. I have to do it. I’m going to get it,” Eva said.

Joe then asked again, “Please.” But Eva’s mind was set. “This has to be me. I have to learn to do it myself. I have to do this.” That’s the toughness we’ve seen from Eva all season. She knows her situation with her autism, and that there will be times she will get overstimulated, and she fights through it. Here Joe was offering to fast-pass her to the final two, and she wanted no part of it. Again, impressive.

But unlike the last event, this was no mere two-person show. Because there was also the player that was putting Eva into fire to begin with. Kyle heard Eva’s pain and struggle and begin to struggle himself with what he had done. “It’s hard to hear somebody go through something like that and know you have a part to play in it. What I thought was going to be an easy decision and what I treated as an easy decision is anything but that.”

Kyle was so upset he started to practice making fire and was considering taking on Kamilla himself. “I’m not a coward either and I’m not afraid to put myself in fire.” Eva’s insistence on pushing through her pain rendered Kyle’s potential offer, like Joe’s, moot. But could she win?

You could sense Eva’s anxiety as soon as she arrived at Tribal Council and saw the materials were different. I’ve heard this from several other contestants who have competed at fire — that they were thrown by the different materials at their disposal at Tribal Council. But when the contest started, it was Kamilla who was struggling. Her leg was cramping, her hands were shaking, and most importantly, her fire was not lighting.

Meanwhile, Eva had a raging fire clearly worthy of burning both of Michael Skupin’s hands off. It was dancing all over the rope. Mary declared the challenge over. And then, the wind shifted. And then, Eva’s fire started dropping, and dropping, and dropping. “What am I doing wrong?” she cried repeatedly through tears.

Joe attempted to keep her calm, and he wasn’t the only one. Even Kamilla was offering encouragement while futilely attempting to get a spark herself. Eventually, Eva recovered and burned the rope, earning her place in the final three.

I don’t know why I just went through all of that. You saw it. You know what happened. You didn’t need me to regurgitate it all. But I thought it was a pretty amazing look at the entire final four. Each of them had a part to play in this one incident, and each of them showed a level of comportment rarely seen in a reality television final four. You may not love the way each of them played the game. You may have wished for flashier players making flashier moves. Totally fair. But when it comes to combining passion and compassion through competition, I’m not sure any final four has done it better.

However, in the end, there could only be one, and that one was Kyle, who took the title in a 5-2-1 vote. And you know what time it was then… pizza and champagne time! Where the two people who just moments earlier lost $1 million have to awkwardly pretend to be happy and celebrate their nationally televised defeat! Yay!

The biggest headline to come out of the After-Show was the news that Kamilla would have won the game had she made it to the final three. If you are Kamilla, I have to imagine that is both really nice and really difficult to hear. So close to soooooooo much money. I have no idea what was going on with David’s masculine and feminine elbow angles for drinking milk other than the takeaway that I am apparently not very masculine. (Not exactly breaking news.) But speaking of consumption, I did love watching Mary and Mitch get down and dirty with that champagne! And check out Kyle making like John Hancock and the Declaration of Independence with his huge, splashy signature all over that season logo. You earned it, buddy!

Well, that about does it. We have tons of extra goodies for you. If you missed it, make sure to check out our pre-finale interviews with the jury and final five, where they drop lots of intel and fun tidbits. We also have our first look at Survivor 49, complete with Jeff Probst weighing in on next season. Also make sure to watch our exclusive deleted scene from the finale and enjoy our exit interviews with Mitch, Kamilla, Eva, Joe, and newly minted champion Kyle.

Also, before we wrap up, just sending out a big thanks to any and all that bothered to read these demented ramblings posing as recaps. The support and kind words are always appreciated. What say we do it again in about… oh, four months? I’ll get started on next season’s scoop of the crispy right now.

Sign up for Entertainment Weekly‘s free daily newsletter to get breaking news, exclusive first looks, recaps, reviews, interviews with your favorite stars, and more.

Read the original article on Entertainment Weekly