The highly anticipated horror debut, Shelby Oaks, from celebrated YouTube film critic Chris Stuckmann, is making waves not just for its chilling narrative but for the inspiring journey behind its creation. Executive produced by horror maestro Mike Flanagan, this project represents a significant triumph for independent filmmaking and the burgeoning influence of digital creators.
For nearly two decades, Chris Stuckmann cultivated a loyal audience of over two million subscribers on YouTube, sharing his insightful and “snackable” film critiques. Now, the 37-year-old Ohio native finds himself in a new spotlight: as the director of his professional feature debut, the horror film Shelby Oaks. Anointed by genre titan Mike Flanagan as executive producer, the film has secured theatrical distribution through Neon, marking a monumental step for the former critic.
The Long Road from Reviewer to Director
While known for his critiques, Stuckmann’s true passion always lay in filmmaking. As a teenager, he created short films heavily influenced by classics like Indiana Jones and Star Wars. His dream solidified, and he later confessed to his YouTube audience in a 2019 retrospective video that he was “really trying to get a feature made,” a dream he had nurtured since recording his first cinema hot take in 2009. He often likened his journey to that of a sculptor who found unexpected success as a car mechanic, with the latter paying the bills while the artistic ambition simmered.
Stuckmann’s inspirations run deep, etched literally onto his skin. His tattoos showcase a rich tapestry of 90s and early 2000s pop culture, including characters from Hey Arnold!, Dragon Ball Z, Ghost in the Shell, and video game icons like Star Fox and Link. Two stand out: the cover art from R.L. Stine’s Goosebumps book, The Haunted Mask, which ignited his desire to write, and a crop circle from M. Night Shyamalan’s Signs, the film that inspired him to direct.
His personal journey, particularly leaving his upbringing as a Jehovah’s Witness in his 20s, profoundly shaped the thematic undercurrents of Shelby Oaks. Stuckmann openly shared with Entertainment Weekly that the film’s exploration of an “unseen force that feels like it’s in control of your life” was a conscious and subconscious reflection of his past. This deeply personal foundation gives the horror narrative an added layer of psychological depth.
Unpacking ‘Shelby Oaks’: A Genre Blend with Personal Roots
Shelby Oaks is a supernatural horror mystery that masterfully blends elements of found footage with traditional filmmaking. The story follows Mia Brennan (played by Camille Sullivan) on a desperate quest to find her sister, Riley (Sarah Durn). Riley was part of a renowned YouTube paranormal investigation group called the Paranormal Paranoids, most of whom met mysterious ends years prior, leaving Riley missing. Newly surfaced evidence reignites Mia’s search, drawing her back into a world touched by religious and cult elements, an entity from their shared childhood.
Neon
Sarah Burn as Riley in ‘Shelby Oaks’
The concept for the film first emerged in 2016 when Stuckmann and his wife, Sam Liz, created a Halloween special with a “cabin in the woods” theme for their YouTube channel. This initial spark slowly grew into the ambition for a feature film, originally conceived as a self-financed project for YouTube. However, the path to cinematic realization was fraught with hurdles, particularly the industry’s skepticism towards digital creators transitioning to traditional filmmaking.
A Crowdfunding Phenomenon
Faced with a lack of traditional backing, Stuckmann turned to Kickstarter. His initial goal was to raise $250,000, which he believed would allow him to produce a scaled-back version of Shelby Oaks. The response, however, was overwhelming. The campaign met its target on the very first day and went on to gross an astonishing $1.39 million, setting a new record for a horror film on the platform. The film’s end credits proudly acknowledge the 14,720 backers who transformed this ambitious vision into a reality.
Stewart Cook/Neon via Getty
Chris Stuckmann at the Los Angeles premiere of ‘Shelby Oaks’
The Endorsement of a Horror Maestro: Mike Flanagan
The success of Stuckmann’s crowdfunding campaign resonated deeply with Mike Flanagan, a filmmaker celebrated for Netflix series like The Haunting of Hill House and The Fall of the House of Usher. Flanagan himself launched a Kickstarter in 2010 to finance his low-budget indie horror, Absentia, raising $25,000 when the platform was still in its infancy. This shared experience forged an immediate connection.
Their relationship began in 2014 when Flanagan, a self-proclaimed fan of Stuckmann’s channel, messaged the critic on Twitter after a positive review of his film Oculus. Over the years, this correspondence blossomed into a genuine friendship. Flanagan anonymously backed Shelby Oaks on Kickstarter, and upon seeing its record-breaking success, he reached out to offer his expertise. Flanagan became an executive producer, providing invaluable guidance on the edit, sound mixing, sound design, and score. He described his goal as simply helping Stuckmann “navigate what it is to finish your first independent feature,” a process he knows intimately from his own career.
Neon
Camille Sullivan as Mia in ‘Shelby Oaks’
Stuckmann credits Flanagan with giving him the confidence to “stop waiting” and pursue his dream, a sentiment he compared to the leap of becoming a father. Flanagan’s endorsement is not just a mentorship; it’s a testament to Stuckmann’s inherent understanding of cinema. Flanagan noted in Entertainment Weekly that Stuckmann “is a classicist” with “an encyclopedic knowledge of genre filmmaking going all the way back to the silent era,” yet he remains “fully a product of that YouTube generation.” This unique blend, Flanagan believes, is “represented really fascinatingly in his storytelling.”
Critical Reception: A Digital Divide
Upon its premiere at the 28th Fantasia International Film Festival in 2024, Shelby Oaks garnered significant attention. Rotten Tomatoes, which eventually granted Stuckmann “approved critic” status after years of labeling him an “influencer,” currently holds the film at a 73 percent “Fresh” rating. The film officially released in theaters on October 24, 2025.
The critical response, as reported by Entertainment Weekly, highlighted a noticeable divide. While legacy media outlets like RogertEbert.com deemed Shelby Oaks “a checklist of clichés,” digital-first press outlets that regularly cover horror, such as Bloody Disgusting, Dread Central, and Collider, offered more decisive praise. io9 aptly summarized it as “a horror film for and by the YouTube generation,” a fitting description for a project born from the digital space and resonating with its sensibilities.
NEON
Mike Flanagan on the set of ‘The Life of Chuck’ with Tom Hiddleston
Stuckmann, who estimates he’s read “a few hundred” reviews, remains philosophical. As he shared with Entertainment Weekly, his filmmaking peers echoed a similar sentiment: “You get bad, you get good. You make money, you don’t make money. The idea is you did your best. It’s out there. That’s a win. You got a film distributed in theaters by one of the best, if not the best, indie distributors on the globe.”
The Future is Bright for a Genre-Agnostic Talent
With Shelby Oaks now released, Stuckmann is far from finished. While he envisions making more horror, he describes himself as “very genre agnostic.” He has other projects simmering, including a drama about Jehovah’s Witnesses, which he hopes to make one day. He describes it as “kind of in the vein of a Spotlight,” aiming to shed light on “quite a bit of stuff going on behind closed doors there that people just don’t know about.” The challenge, as he notes, is selling a concept not based on existing intellectual property, a “straightforward drama” or “chamber piece” without capes, monsters, or ghosts.
Given the incredible journey of Shelby Oaks and the powerful mentorship of Mike Flanagan, it’s clear that Chris Stuckmann has firmly established himself as a compelling new voice in filmmaking. His unique trajectory from respected critic to accomplished director, fueled by fan support and personal conviction, suggests a versatile and exciting career ahead.
