A Rose Ceremony Bombshell! Who Went Home on ‘Bachelor in Paradise’ 2025 Tonight? originally appeared on Parade.
On episode 2 of Bachelor in Paradise season 10, four new women joined the show — Alli Jo Hinkes, Parisa Shifteh, Jill Chin and Susie Evans. The show also introduced a Kissing Booth game that was quite informative, though it happened before Jill and Susie got to the resort.
As the newbies, the new women were all given date cards. Parisa asked Brian Autz on her date, Alli Jo asked Jonathon Johnson on her date, Jill also asked Jonathon (though it was kind of a friends thing), and Susie asked Jeremy Simon on her date.
Below are all the details from episode 2, including who coupled up and which women were sent packing from Bachelor in Paradise season 10 in 2025. Beware of spoilers ahead.
RELATED: ‘Bachelor in Paradise’ Star Breaks Down That ‘Insane’ Rose Ceremony
Who went home in the Bachelor in Paradise Season 10 premiere in 2025 tonight?
The men had the roses this week, and since four new women were introduced, four women had to go home. Here’s who got the boot:
Alli Jo Hinkes
Jill Chin
Zoe McGrady
The remaining eliminated woman appears to be Lexi Young, but that remains to be seen. What happened was that her match from the premiere episode, Justin Glaze, did not offer Lexi a rose. Instead, he offered a rose to his ex-girlfriend Susie. As Susie said, it seemed like he was doing it to give Susie a chance to stay and possibly meet someone when new male contestants are added to the show. But Susie didn’t want to stay that way, and she turned his rose down. Justin then left the set, Susie chased after him, cameramen gave chase to them, and then Lexi walked off set in a different direction, and the show left us with a “to be continued”…
RELATED: ‘Bachelor in Paradise’ Star Admits Sliding Into Match’s DMs Before the Show (Exclusive)
Who matched during the Kissing Booth game on Bachelor in Paradise season 10 episode 2?
For the Kissing Booth game, each contestant — the six couples left from the premiere, plus the two new women, Alli Jo and Parisa — was given an iPad and was able to vote on which members of the opposite sex they wanted to kiss in the Kissing Booth. Only couples that matched ended up in the Kissing Booth.
Many of the men “swiped right” on every girl just to see who would match with them. Spencer and Justin were the only two who stayed completely loyal to the woman who gave them a rose in week 1.
The matches were as follows:
Jonathon matched with Alexe, Alli Jo, Parisa, and Bailey
Brian matched with Zoe and Parisa
Spencer only matched with Jess
Jeremy only matched with Bailey, though he chose 3 other girls who did not choose him (womp womp)
Justin only matched with Lexi
Dale matched with Alexe, Kat, Alli Jo and Zoe
🌹 SIGN UP for our The Bachelor newsletter to stay up to date on the latest Bachelor Nation news, exclusive interviews, episode recaps & more 🌹
Who are the remaining couples on Bachelor in Paradise Season 10 in 2025?
Spencer and Jess
Dale and Kat
Jeremy and Bailey
Brian and Parisa
Jonathon and Alexe
Justin and …?
Who is left on Bachelor in Paradise Season 10 in 2025?
Just FYI — the Golden Bachelor(ette) contestants were not on episode 2, but they are finally showing up in episode 3, so they are listed below.
Alexe Godin
28, Pediatric speech therapist, New Brunswick, Canada
Grant Ellis’ Bachelor season 29
April Kirkwood
67, Therapist, Port St. Lucie, FL
Gerry Turner’s Golden Bachelor season 1
Bailey Brown
28, Social media manager, Atlanta, GA
Grant Ellis’ Bachelor season 29
Brian Autz
34, Aesthetics consultant, Boynton Beach, FL
Jenn Tran’s Bachelorette season 21
Charles “CK” King
62, Portfolio manager, Rancho Palos Verdes, CA
Joan Vassos’ Golden Bachelorette season 1
Dale Moss
36, Former NFL wide receiver, Brandon, SD
Clare Crawley’s Bachelorette season 16
Gary Levingston
66, Retired finance executive, Palm Desert, CA
Joan Vassos’ Golden Bachelorette season 1
Jack Lencioni
69, Caterer, Chicago, IL
Joan Vassos’ Golden Bachelorette season 1
Jeremy Simon
31, Real estate investor, New York
Jenn Tran’s Bachelorette season 21
Jess Edwards
26, Executive assistant, San Diego, CA
Joey Graziadei’s Bachelor season 28
Jonathon Johnson
28, Creative director, Los Angeles
Jenn Trann’s Bachelorette season 21
Justin Glaze
31, Painter and sales consultant, Baltimore, MD
Katie Thurston’s Bachelorette season 17 and Bachelor in Paradise season 8
Kat Izzo
29, Registered nurse, Tampa, FL
Zach Shallcross’ Bachelor season 27 and Bachelor in Paradise season 9
Kathy Swarts
72, Retired educational consultant, Austin, TX
Gerry Turner’s Golden Bachelor season 1
Keith Gordon
63, Girl dad, Columbus, IN
Joan Vassos’ Golden Bachelorette season 1
Kim Buike
70, Retired Navy captain, Seattle
Joan Vassos’ Golden Bachelorette season 1
Leslie Fhima
66, Fitness instructor, Golden Valley, MN
Gerry Turner’s Golden Bachelor season 1
Lexi Young?
31, Digital strategist, Pataskala, OH
Joey Graziadei’s Bachelor season 28
Natascha Hardee
62, Pro-aging coach and speaker, New York
Gerry Turner’s Golden Bachelor season 1
Parisa Shifteh
30, pediatric behavior analyst, Birmingham, MI
Grant Ellis’ Bachelor season 29
Ralph “RJ” Johnson
66, Financial advisor, Irvine, CA
Joan Vassos’ Golden Bachelorette season 1
Spencer Conley
32, Pet portrait entrepreneur, Dallas, TX
Jenn Tran’s Bachelorette season 21
Susie Evans?
31, wedding videographer, Poquoson, VA
Clayton Echard’s Bachelor season 26
Additionally, though not introduced in the premiere episode, there are three more younger contestants who were revealed in a trailer for the show. We’re sure they are not the only other contestants joining the season, but they are the three shown in the trailer.
Lea Cayanan
24, Account manager, Waipahu, HI
Joey Graziadei’s Bachelor season 28
Sean McLaughlin
27, Software sales rep, Troy, NY
Charity Lawson’s Bachelorette season 20 and Bachelor in Paradise season 9
Allyshia Gupta
29, Interior designer, Wesley Chapel, FL
Grant Ellis’ Bachelor season 29
Bachelor in Paradise airs Monday nights at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC, though the continuation of the July 14 episode airs Tuesday, July 15 at 8 p.m.
A Rose Ceremony Bombshell! Who Went Home on ‘Bachelor in Paradise’ 2025 Tonight? first appeared on Parade on Jul 15, 2025
This story was originally reported by Parade on Jul 15, 2025, where it first appeared.
