The No. 1 Mistake People Make With High-Yield Savings Accounts in May 2025

Image source: Getty Images

Back in my early 20s, I remember bragging to my cousin one day that my bank balance had crossed the $30,000 mark. I expected a high five — that’s a huge feat for a young saver! But instead, he called me an idiot.

Looking for a secure place to grow your savings? See our expert picks for the best FDIC-insured high-yield savings accounts available today – enjoy peace of mind with competitive rates.

Then he lectured me about something I’d never heard before: financial hoarding.

You see, once your savings reaches a certain point, extra cash stops helping you and starts holding you back.

In fact, holding onto an extra $20,000 in cash could cost you over $348,000 in missed growth over 30 years. Here’s how.

Why too much in a high-yield savings account can cost you

High-yield savings accounts are fantastic for your emergency fund and short-term needs. They’re safe, they’re liquid, and right now the best high-yield savings accounts offer around 4.00% APY.

But even the best HYSA rates can’t compete with long-term investing returns.

You might be cheering about your 4.00% HYSA right now. But a simple stock market index fund has historically returned closer to 10% annually.

Let’s say you have an extra $20,000 sitting in a savings account. Here’s how much it could grow over time if you either left it in savings or invested it and earned 10% per year:

Data source: Author’s calculations.

Can you believe how much is forfeited by saving cash instead of investing? It’s a difference of hundreds of thousands of dollars.

Most people will need at least $1 million to retire comfortably. And saving is not going to get there alone. Investing is what grows your money into real long-term wealth.

By the way — Getting a 4.00% APY on a high-yield account is historically high. Interest rates are very likely to drop later this year — and beyond.

Don’t have a high-yield savings account yet? Compare today’s top HYSA rates and start earning more on your emergency fund.

Try the bucket method to organize your money

One of the most helpful things I ever did was set up “money buckets.” Instead of having one giant savings account, I broke my goals down like this:

1. Short-term bucket (0-2 years):

This is all the money you need to keep in cash, so you can access it immediately if needed.

• Emergency fund (three to six months of living expenses)

• Travel fund

• Upcoming large expenses (taxes, home projects)

Keep all this money in a high-yield savings account. It’s safe, it’s accessible, and it earns great interest short term.

2. Mid-term bucket (2-5 years):

This bucket is for medium-term financial goals. They could be things like:

• Saving for a house down payment or a remodel

• A big move or sabbatical

• A new car purchase

This money might also be suited towards an HYSA given that rates are currently high. But it can also be invested conservatively for slightly higher growth. Certificates of deposit (CDs) are a great place to start.

3. Long-term bucket (5 or more years):

This last bucket is for money tied to long-term goals. Think goals like:

• Retirement nest egg

• Kids’ college fund

• General wealth-building

Since you won’t be touching these funds for decades, it’s OK to invest with a bit more risk. Short-term volatility doesn’t matter as much, because the ups and downs smooth out over the long run.

A great place to invest these funds is in your workplace 401(k) plan, an IRA, or a brokerage account.

Need help building a retirement plan? With our partner, SmartAsset, you can get matched with up to three fiduciary advisors so you can get professional advice.

This simple structure helped me get super clear on what my money was doing — and made it easier to invest confidently without worrying I’d need that cash anytime soon.

The bottom line

Saving money is smart. But once you’ve hit your emergency fund target, letting extra cash pile up in a high-yield savings account could actually slow you down.

Use the bucket method to stay organized. Keep your short-term cash safe, and invest the rest to let it grow.

Alert: highest cash back card we’ve seen now has 0% intro APR into 2026

This credit card is not just good – it’s so exceptional that our experts use it personally. It features a 0% intro APR for 15 months, a cash back rate of up to 5%, and all somehow for no annual fee!

Click here to read our full review for free and apply in just 2 minutes.

We’re firm believers in the Golden Rule, which is why editorial opinions are ours alone and have not been previously reviewed, approved, or endorsed by included advertisers. Motley Fool Money does not cover all offers on the market. Editorial content from Motley Fool Money is separate from The Motley Fool editorial content and is created by a different analyst team.Joel O’Leary has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends Barclays Plc. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.