While four players head to New York for the Heisman ceremony, the real conversation is about the players left behind—especially a game-wrecking linebacker from Texas Tech who is redefining what a Heisman contender looks like. We break down the snubs, the odds, and the shifting landscape of college football’s most coveted award.
The stage is set in New York City. Four finalists—Indiana QB Fernando Mendoza, Vanderbilt QB Diego Pavia, Notre Dame RB Jeremiah Love, and Ohio State QB Julian Sayin—will await the announcement of the 2025 Heisman Trophy winner. But as the lights shine on them, the most significant story of this Heisman race may be unfolding in the shadows, with the players who finished just outside the ceremony’s velvet ropes.
On Thursday, the Heisman Trust revealed the players who landed in the 5th through 10th spots, and the list provides a fascinating snapshot of what excellence looks like in modern college football. More importantly, it highlights a tectonic shift in voter perspective, spearheaded by a defensive force in Lubbock, Texas.
The Defensive Player Who Crashed the Party
The name at the top of the “just missed” list is Jacob Rodriguez, the Texas Tech linebacker who finished fifth overall. In an era where the Heisman has become almost exclusively a quarterback’s award, Rodriguez’s finish isn’t just a consolation prize; it’s a statement. He was the highest vote-getter not invited to the ceremony and stands as a testament to pure, unadulterated defensive dominance.
His stat line is staggering: 117 tackles, 11 tackles for loss, 4 interceptions, 2 fumble recoveries, and an incredible 7 forced fumbles. These aren’t just numbers; they are game-changing plays that propelled Texas Tech to its first-ever Big 12 title and a coveted No. 4 seed in the College Football Playoff. Rodriguez wasn’t just a player on a great defense; he *was* the defense, a one-man wrecking crew who dictated the terms of every game. His high finish challenges the long-held notion that only offensive players can be the “most outstanding” in the sport, a definition upheld by the Heisman Trophy Trust for decades.
A Field of Elite Talent
Rodriguez wasn’t the only elite talent to just miss the cut. The full list of players ranked 5-10 showcases the depth of skill across the country:
- 5. Jacob Rodriguez, LB, Texas Tech
- 6. Jeremiah Smith, WR, Ohio State
- 7. Gunner Stockton, QB, Georgia
- 8. Trinidad Chambliss, QB, Ole Miss
- 9. Caleb Downs, DB, Ohio State
- 10. Haynes King, QB, Georgia Tech
Two things immediately stand out. First, the presence of two defensive players in the top ten—Rodriguez and Ohio State defensive back Caleb Downs—is remarkable. Second, the list features a blend of established powers and programs on the rise. Ohio State receiver Jeremiah Smith followed up a phenomenal freshman campaign with 80 catches for 1,086 yards and 11 touchdowns for the No. 2 seeded Buckeyes. Meanwhile, Georgia Tech QB Haynes King became the first Yellow Jacket to crack the top 10 since the legendary Calvin Johnson, a massive achievement for the program.
The Betting Favorite and the Long Shots
Despite the compelling stories bubbling under the surface, the race in New York appears to be a runaway. Indiana quarterback Fernando Mendoza is the prohibitive favorite to hoist the trophy. His incredible season, which culminated in a Big Ten Championship victory over powerhouse Ohio State, has made him a heavy favorite in the eyes of oddsmakers. Current betting lines from BetMGM show Mendoza at an astounding -1200.
His closest competitor, Vanderbilt’s Diego Pavia, sits at a distant +700, a testament to the perceived gap between the top candidate and the rest of the field. The other two finalists, Jeremiah Love (150-1) and Julian Sayin (500-1), are considered significant long shots, their invitations a recognition of stellar seasons rather than a reflection of a real chance to win.
Ultimately, while Mendoza is poised to take home the hardware, the 2025 Heisman vote will be remembered for the players who broadened the award’s horizons. The success of defensive stars like Jacob Rodriguez proves that impact is no longer measured solely in touchdowns and passing yards. It’s measured in momentum-swinging turnovers, championship-clinching stops, and the sheer will to dominate—qualities that define the very essence of college football’s most outstanding player.
For the fastest, most insightful analysis in sports, stick with onlytrustedinfo.com. We deliver the context and depth that goes beyond the headlines, ensuring you always know why the story matters.
