As the U.S. men’s national team gears up for the 2026 World Cup on home soil, the form of its star-studded attacking core is raising serious alarms. Christian Pulisic’s AC Milan slump, Gio Reyna’s latest injury setback, and Malik Tillman’s goal drought create a perfect storm of uncertainty for manager Gregg Berhalter.
The 2026 World Cup is just around the corner, but for the U.S. men’s national team, a cloud of uncertainty hangs over its most potent attacking weapons. The start of the new year has been unkind to three of the USMNT’s most crucial players: Christian Pulisic, Gio Reyna, and Malik Tillman. Their combined struggles—injuries, poor form, and a critical lack of goals—raise urgent questions about the team’s ability to deliver on home soil.
The Captain’s Slump: Christian Pulisic’s Silent January
For Christian Pulisic, the new year has been a stark contrast to his dominant first half of the season with AC Milan. After being the unquestioned star of the Rossoneri’s attack, the USMNT captain has gone completely cold. Pulisic is now without a goal or assist in six total games in 2026, a worrying statistic for a player whose primary role is to create and finish chances.
His performance in Milan’s recent 1-1 draw at Roma was particularly telling. Brought on in the 69th minute, Pulisic was a non-factor as his team sat back to preserve a point. The lack of attacking opportunities was by design, but Pulisic was unable to influence the game when chances did arise.
The root of the problem appears to be fitness. AC Milan coach Max Allegri admitted earlier this month that the 27-year-old was not fully recovered from a hamstring injury suffered in the fall. Pulisic has started just three of his side’s six games in January, and his lack of sharpness is evident. With Milan now five points back of first-place Inter, Allegri will need his star forward fully fit and firing if the Rossoneri are to mount a title challenge. For the USMNT, the hope is that Pulisic regains his form before the World Cup, but the clock is ticking.
The Inevitable Setback: Gio Reyna’s Latest Injury Woes
In what has become a depressingly familiar narrative in recent years, Gio Reyna has suffered another injury setback. The creative midfielder missed Borussia Mönchengladbach’s 3-0 defeat to Stuttgart on Sunday due to “muscular problems,” the club confirmed. While the severity of the injury is not yet known, any absence is a significant blow for Reyna and the USMNT.
This latest setback continues a pattern of inconsistency that has plagued Reyna’s career. After a promising start at Gladbach following his move from Borussia Dortmund, the 21-year-old has struggled to build momentum. In 14 appearances for his new club, including five starts, Reyna has yet to tally a single goal or assist. He remains a player of immense talent, capable of changing a game with a moment of magic, but his inability to stay fit and deliver consistently has raised doubts about his role in the USMNT’s World Cup plans.
The Transfer Struggle: Malik Tillman’s Goal Drought
Malik Tillman’s move to Bayer Leverkusen was supposed to be the next step in his development, a chance to establish himself as a regular in the Bundesliga. Instead, his first season has been defined by a significant goal drought. The 23-year-old has not scored or assisted a goal since November 22, a staggering run of 11 games across all competitions.
Leverkusen paid a club-record €35 million transfer fee for Tillman, and that investment was made with the expectation of goal production. While he has maintained his work-rate and contributed in possession, the primary reason for his transfer has gone unfulfilled. With just three goals all season, Tillman is falling well short of expectations. His recent demotion to the bench for Leverkusen’s last two matches suggests that head coach Xabi Alonso is losing patience. For the USMNT, this is a major concern, as Tillman was seen as a key part of the future attack.
The Silver Linings: Agyemang and McKennie Shine Amidst the Gloom
While the struggles of Pulisic, Reyna, and Tillman paint a concerning picture, there are still some bright spots for American players abroad. Patrick Agyemang continues to thrive with Derby County. The striker found the net for the second time in three games on Friday, Jan. 23, opening the scoring in a 1-1 draw with West Brom. Agyemang’s goal was of the opportunistic variety, as he took advantage of a mistake from the goalkeeper to bundle home. He’s now scored eight goals in his debut season with Derby and has even been linked with a move to the Premier League, making a strong case for a World Cup roster spot.
Similarly, Weston McKennie is experiencing a career resurgence at Juventus. Playing as a makeshift striker, McKennie has been a revelation for the Italian giants. With five goals on the season, he is just one shy of his career high and has scored in three consecutive Champions League matches. After Juve’s 3-0 win over Napoli, head coach Luciano Spalletti was full of praise, calling McKennie “the perfect striker.” “He fights, he’s strong in the air and he can jump high. He plays to get results because he makes decisions,” Spalletti said. McKennie’s versatility and newfound goal-scoring touch could provide a much-needed boost to the USMNT’s attack.
The Fan Fallout: Trade Rumors and What-If Scenarios
The struggles of these high-profile players have inevitably fueled fan-driven theories and trade rumors online. For Pulisic, the question is whether his Milan move was the right one, with some suggesting a return to the Premier League could reignite his career. Reyna’s situation has led to speculation about a potential loan move away from Gladbach to find regular football and regain his confidence. Tillman’s dip in form has some questioning whether Leverkusen was the right environment for him to develop, with calls for a move to a club where he can be the focal point of the attack.
These “what-if” scenarios dominate fan forums and social media, but they highlight the genuine anxiety surrounding the USMNT’s attack. With the World Cup less than a year away, the team needs its best players to be at their peak. The inability of Pulisic, Reyna, and Tillman to find form simultaneously creates a massive hole in the team’s creative and goal-scolving capabilities. Manager Gregg Berhalter’s options are becoming increasingly limited, and the pressure is mounting for these stars to turn their seasons around.
The situation is a critical test for the USMNT’s depth and resilience. Can players like McKennie and Agyemang step up and seize their opportunities? Can the established stars overcome their respective slumps in time for the biggest tournament of their lives? The answers to these questions will determine whether the USMNT can fulfill its potential on home soil or if this period of individual struggles will derail its World Cup dreams.
For the fastest, most authoritative analysis of all the breaking news that matters, stay with onlytrustedinfo.com. We provide the context and insight you need to understand the stories shaping the world of sports.
