California resident Nyree Hinton has been in the news recently for filing a class action lawsuit against Tesla. He claims Tesla’s odometers are over-reporting mileage to accelerate the time it takes for the vehicles to fall out of warranty. When he purchased his 2020 Model Y in December of 2022, it had 36,722 miles on the clock. However, Hinton was recently on the hook for a $10,000 suspension repair bill that would have been covered had his basic warranty (good for 50,000 miles or 4 years) still been intact.
The Case
It didn’t take long for things to get extra complicated. Along with claims of accelerated mileage, Hinton stated that he believes Tesla’s odometer algorithm relies on energy consumption, driver behavior, and “predictive algorithms” rather than keeping track of the real mileage driven. He cites his driving history, with one of his daily routes covering 20 miles and the Tesla reporting 72. We’ve attached the case below for your review—click the image to read.
Before we go any further, we should clarify that odometers do not have to be 100 percent accurate. The Society of Automotive Engineers allows for a margin of error of plus or minus four percent. So, given we bet the over on the SAE’s standard, how much extra mileage would that pile on over the lifetime of your vehicle? Keeping the numbers easy, for every 1,000 miles, you would only gain an extra 40 miles on the clock. If we take the 36,722-mile odometer reading Hinton mentioned at the time he purchased his Model Y, a 4-percent discrepancy would only add 1,468.88 miles. Over the next two years before the repair, that’s not a difference that would take his vehicle out of warranty.
What Does The Evidence Look Like?
One potential hole in this case is that warranties aren’t just measured by mileage—most modern warranties will age out after reaching a mileage figure or a set amount of time. In Tesla’s case, the basic warranty Hinton’s Model Y came with expires after 50,000 miles or 4 years. This has become standard practice, as motorists can drive wildly different distances every year. For context, the United States Federal Highway Administration says we drive an average of 13,000 miles a year. However, I rarely put more than 3,000 miles on my car annually, as I live within walking distance of my office and most of the amenities I need are nearby.
The other question mark on this case is… well… the evidence. Hinton claims his Model Y’s odometer reported an additional 72 miles at the end of the day when his usual route was only 20 miles long. That’s a 360 percent increase, which is well outside the acceptable margin of error, and means that someone would have definitely noticed before Hinton. However, if we assume the wild inaccuracy is true, Tesla would be on the hook for odometer fraud on essentially every vehicle it has sold. Spoiler alert: the United States has zero sense of humor when it comes to fiddling around with odometers.
The Penalty Box
This case is unique, as most instances of odometer fraud involve rolling the odometer back to reduce the mileage. Putting the anecdotal evidence aside for this case, the United States takes odometer fraud very seriously, and for good reason—thus far, it’s cost American consumers an estimated $1 billion annually. It’s highly illegal, and carries cumulative penalties for every proven instance of tampering.
That’s a scary thought, but our verdict is that it will be difficult for Hinton to prove any wrongdoing. Should Tesla be found guilty, they would be liable up to $250,000 for every vehicle they’ve possibly tampered with—for context, Tesla sold over a million Model Y’s in 2023 alone. If the brand is indeed measuring mileage inaccurately, this could be a Volkswagen-dieselgate-level scandal.
Do we think Hinton vs. Tesla will ever reach that level? We highly doubt it. It makes us question why the law firm would take on the case with so little convincing evidence to speak of. That being said, Tesla has a track record of settling in court, so perhaps that’s the play here.
You Might Also Like
The Do’s and Don’ts of Using Painter’s Tape
The Best Portable BBQ Grills for Cooking Anywhere
Can a Smart Watch Prolong Your Life?
