The Enduring Shadow: Prince Andrew Faces New Police Investigation Over Alleged Smear Campaign Against Virginia Giuffre

9 Min Read

Prince Andrew is under a fresh police investigation following leaked emails suggesting he pressured a Metropolitan Police officer to find incriminating information on Virginia Giuffre, intensifying scrutiny on his past connections to Jeffrey Epstein and sparking renewed public outrage over the alleged misuse of royal influence.

The scandal surrounding Prince Andrew and his association with convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein continues to cast a long shadow over the British monarchy. New revelations from leaked emails have now triggered a formal investigation by the Metropolitan Police, focusing on allegations that the Duke of York attempted to orchestrate a smear campaign against his accuser, Virginia Giuffre.

These latest claims suggest a disturbing misuse of power and resources, reigniting public debate about accountability within the royal family and the lengths to which individuals may go to discredit victims of sexual assault and trafficking. The incident comes at a time when Andrew has already been stripped of his military honors and royal titles, leaving his public image in tatters.

The Bombshell Email: A Look at the Allegations

According to reports from The Daily Mail, leaked emails dating back to 2011 reveal Prince Andrew instructed Queen Elizabeth’s deputy press secretary that he had provided a police protection officer with Virginia Giuffre’s U.S. Social Security number and date of birth. His alleged intent was for the officer to “dig into her criminal record,” hoping to uncover information that could discredit her. This exchange reportedly occurred just before the infamous 2001 photograph of Andrew with a then 17-year-old Giuffre, alongside Epstein accomplice Ghislaine Maxwell, was published.

The Metropolitan Police confirmed they are “actively looking into the claims made” following the surfacing of these emails. This move underscores the serious nature of the allegations, as they imply the potential involvement of a taxpayer-funded police officer in a private attempt to undermine a sexual assault accuser. Labour’s Shadow Energy Secretary, Ed Miliband, highlighted the gravity of the situation, stating that it is “absolutely not the way that close protection officers should be used,” as reported by People.

Virginia Giuffre’s Claims and Andrew’s Denials

Virginia Giuffre, who tragically died by suicide in April at the age of 41, had publicly accused Prince Andrew of sexual assault, claiming he was part of Jeffrey Epstein’s trafficking network and raped her when she was a minor. She filed a civil lawsuit against Andrew in 2021, which was settled out of court the following year for a reported $12 million. Despite the settlement, Andrew has consistently and vehemently denied all allegations against him, maintaining his innocence.

The settlement agreement stated that Andrew would donate to Giuffre’s charity in support of victims’ rights and demonstrate regret for his association with Epstein. However, it explicitly contained no admission of guilt. Giuffre’s posthumous memoir, Nobody’s Girl: A Memoir of Surviving Abuse and Fighting for Justice, published on October 21, recounts her alleged experiences with Andrew in detail, claiming he “believed having sex with me was his birthright.”

MediaPunch Inc/Alamy Stock Photo Prince Andrew, Virginia Giuffre and Ghislaine Maxwell in early 2001
The infamous 2001 photograph featuring Prince Andrew, Virginia Giuffre, and Ghislaine Maxwell.

The Role of the Infamous Photograph and Ghislaine Maxwell

A crucial element in Virginia Giuffre’s allegations has always been the photograph showing her with Prince Andrew and Ghislaine Maxwell. Andrew’s legal team had previously questioned the authenticity of this image, intending to bring in an expert to analyze it during the civil trial. However, a leaked email exchange between Epstein’s former lawyer, Alan Dershowitz, and Ghislaine Maxwell in 2015 appears to confirm the photograph’s credibility.

In this exchange, Maxwell stated, “it looks real. I think it is.” This admission from Maxwell, who also appears in the picture, significantly weakened Andrew’s defense regarding the photo’s veracity, lending substantial credibility to Giuffre’s claims, as noted by royal commentator Richard Fitzwilliams to GB News. The timing of Andrew’s alleged request for a background check on Giuffre, just hours before the photo’s publication in 2011, suggests a preemptive attempt to undermine her potential public statements.

Renewed Scrutiny and Calls for Accountability

The new allegations have led to widespread condemnation and renewed calls for accountability. Legal experts have voiced concerns about the implications of Prince Andrew’s alleged actions:

  • Charlotte Proudman, a prominent barrister, described Andrew’s actions as “utterly despicable and reprehensible,” suggesting “there could be legal implications for Andrew.”
  • Spencer Kuvin, a lawyer representing nine of Epstein’s victims, called smearing a survivor “the oldest play in the handbook” and hoped authorities would “prosecute him for any laws he may have broken.”
  • Mark Stephens, a data and privacy expert, indicated “reasons to investigate whether a criminal conspiracy has occurred here.”

Virginia Giuffre’s family responded to the revelations by saying they “expose the lengths to which those implicated try to discredit and defame survivors. The truth will surface and there will be no shadows in which they can hide.” They have also renewed their request to King Charles to strip Andrew of his title of Prince and called for a full investigation into how Andrew obtained Giuffre’s private information, including her sensitive Social Security number.

The Broader Impact on Prince Andrew and the Monarchy

The resurfacing of these allegations comes shortly after Andrew was forced to relinquish all of his remaining royal titles and honors. This decision followed new damaging revelations in the Mail on Sunday about his continued friendship with Jeffrey Epstein, including a newly surfaced email from 2011 where Andrew allegedly told Epstein, “we are in this together,” after previously claiming to have cut ties.

Max Mumby/Indigo/Getty  Prince Andrew in September 2025
Prince Andrew pictured in September 2025, facing ongoing scrutiny.

The cumulative effect of these scandals has taken a severe toll on Prince Andrew’s reputation and his standing within the royal family. His disastrous 2019 BBC Newsnight interview, where he expressed no regret for his friendship with Epstein, further alienated him from the public. The ongoing police investigation into his alleged attempts to discredit Virginia Giuffre ensures that the shadow of the Epstein scandal will continue to follow him, making any return to public royal life highly unlikely.

This evolving narrative not only highlights Andrew’s personal struggles but also forces the monarchy to confront difficult questions about the behavior of its members and the perceived use of influence. The unwavering commitment of victims and their families to seek truth and justice continues to bring these critical issues to light.

Share This Article