After critically acclaimed performances in The Holdovers, Paul Giamatti reveals his guiding principle for selecting projects: a compelling narrative always takes precedence over the size or type of the role, opening doors to exciting new ventures in sci-fi and horror.
Paul Giamatti has long been celebrated as one of cinema’s most versatile and compelling actors, consistently delivering memorable performances in both leading and supporting capacities. From the quirky comic book artist Harvey Pekar in American Splendor to the empathetic teacher Paul Hunham in The Holdovers, Giamatti’s career is a testament to his unique talent. Now, after receiving significant accolades for his recent work, the acclaimed actor has shed light on the core philosophy that guides his diverse filmography: an unwavering focus on the story itself.
The ‘Story First’ Approach
In a recent interview with People, Giamatti articulated his primary criterion for choosing projects, stating, “I really look for the story to be interesting, you know, and then the role is kind of secondary.” This revelation offers fans a deeper understanding of the method behind his selections, explaining why he gravitates towards projects like the beloved Downton Abbey movie series, where he reprised his role as Harold Levinson.
His sentiment highlights a dedication to the narrative tapestry, rather than solely the spotlight. For Giamatti, the intricate web of “a million stories going on at once” within Downton Abbey made it an irresistible opportunity. This approach underscores a career built on artistic integrity and a deep appreciation for well-crafted tales.
The ‘Holdovers’ Effect: A Newfound Freedom
Giamatti’s critically acclaimed performance in The Holdovers proved to be a pivotal moment, earning him a Golden Globe Award for Best Actor in a Motion Picture – Musical or Comedy and an Oscar nomination. This recognition, he shared, has offered him a sense of liberation in his career choices. “I mean you do feel freed up to kind of do whatever you want to do, you know?” he remarked to People. This newfound creative freedom means Giamatti is now more empowered than ever to pursue projects that genuinely excite him, regardless of traditional career trajectories.
This period of his career, Giamatti reflects, feels like “gravy,” allowing him to embrace diverse opportunities simply because they are “wonderful things” that come along. This perspective is a gift to fans, promising an even wider array of compelling roles in the years to come.
Venturing into Sci-Fi and Horror
One of the most exciting outcomes of this artistic freedom is Giamatti’s expressed desire to delve into new genres. He specifically voiced an interest in science fiction and horror films, a wish he has already begun to fulfill. In 2025, he has expanded his résumé with roles in high-profile sci-fi productions such as Black Mirror and Star Trek: Starfleet Academy, signaling a fresh direction for his career. This move is particularly thrilling for fans who appreciate his ability to inhabit complex characters in any setting.
Beyond sci-fi, Giamatti is also making a foray into horror. He is set to star in a key role in Eli Roth’s TV adaptation of the Hostel series, described as an “elevated thriller.” While details are still emerging, with Roth reportedly writing episodes, the project is actively “getting it set up somewhere,” according to Giamatti, as reported by The Hollywood Reporter. This exploration into darker, more intense narratives promises to showcase yet another facet of Giamatti’s incredible range.
A Storied Career Defined by Diversity
Giamatti’s career, spanning over 50 film titles since his debut in 1990, has always been marked by an incredible breadth of roles. From the animated worlds of Robots and Turbo to gritty dramas like Saving Private Ryan and 12 Years a Slave, he has never shied away from variety. His performances in films like Man on the Moon, The Truman Show, and The Illusionist demonstrate his consistent ability to elevate any story he’s a part of, whether in a fleeting cameo or a leading role.
Born on June 6, 1967, Giamatti’s intellectual background, with an English degree from Yale University and a Master’s from the Yale School of Drama, has undoubtedly informed his discerning eye for compelling narratives. His journey from regional theater to a recognized Hollywood veteran highlights a path paved with thoughtful choices and a genuine passion for storytelling.
As Paul Giamatti continues to expand his artistic horizons, prioritizing the quality of the story above all else, fans can anticipate a future filled with even more captivating and unexpected performances. His unique blend of talent and a narrative-driven approach ensures that every project he undertakes will be, at its heart, an interesting story worth telling.
