Halloween became ‘All Hallows’ Eve’ for Mayci Neeley and Mikayla Matthews as the Mormon Wives besties delivered a spot-on Gossip Girl tribute, with Mikayla‘s striking likeness to Leighton Meester as Blair Waldorf and Mayci‘s effortless Serena van der Woodsen proving why they’re fan favorites, and stirring excitement for the upcoming Season 3.
The highly anticipated third season of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives is almost here, and with it, the promise of more drama and revelations. But before the new episodes drop, stars Mayci Neeley and Mikayla Matthews have already made headlines by embracing the Halloween spirit with costumes that have sent fans into a frenzy: a flawless recreation of Gossip Girl‘s iconic duo, Serena van der Woodsen and Blair Waldorf.
Known for their friendship and their prominent role in the show’s unfolding narratives, Mayci and Mikayla are no strangers to being in the thick of the action. From the Season 3 trailer, viewers already know they’ll be grilling Vanderpump Villa alum Marciano Brunette about his alleged affair with Jessi Ngatikaura, showcasing their determination to uncover the truth. Their recent Halloween escapade, however, brought a lighter, yet equally captivating, side of the duo to light.
A Picture-Perfect ‘Gossip Girl’ Transformation
For their Halloween look, Mayci Neeley and Mikayla Matthews stepped into the designer shoes of two of television’s most famous private school students. Mayci flawlessly embodied the bohemian chic of Serena van der Woodsen, while Mikayla channeled the sophisticated, headband-wearing charm of Blair Waldorf. Their attention to detail was impeccable, sporting “their best sexy, private school attire” to truly capture the essence of the Upper East Side elite.
The duo shared their transformations across Instagram, quickly garnering thousands of likes and enthusiastic comments. Mikayla posted a video captioned, “Our best costume yet @maycineeley,” featuring the iconic Gossip Girl voice-over declaring, “All Hallows’ Eve. The one day of the year it’s socially acceptable to play dress-up.” The clip then showed the ladies dancing, prompting an outpouring of fan approval.
Fans Crown Them the Winners of Halloween
The response from the fan community was immediate and overwhelmingly positive. Comments flooded their posts, celebrating their uncanny resemblance and creative execution:
- “You two win the internet,” one follower declared.
- “Welcome back gossip girls,” another added, complete with fire and clapping emojis.
- “You and Leighton [Meester] are twins,” a third fan noted, highlighting Mikayla’s striking similarity to the actress who portrayed Blair Waldorf.
For Mikayla Matthews, the comparisons to Leighton Meester are a long-standing observation. She has “previously told People” that she regularly gets mistaken for the actress. “So when I first started TikTok back in the beginning of 2020, I’d get it all the time. Even now, when I meet people, they’re like, ‘Oh wow, you’re Leighton [Meester],’ or ‘You look just like Blair,’ she says, nodding to the actress’ Gossip Girl character.” This Halloween costume proved to be a full-circle moment, further solidifying the comparison.
Mikayla, clearly flattered, has even expressed her desire for a meeting with Meester, stating, “I’m trying to manifest a meetup!” She reiterated this sentiment in her video caption, writing, “Manifesting this meet up in the future 👀💅🏼.”
Mayci’s Inner Serena Shines
Meanwhile, Mayci Neeley shared her own video, lip-syncing to Kristen Bell’s iconic Gossip Girl voice-over: “Because if looks could kill, we wouldn’t want to be Dan Humphrey.” The clip featured a surprise appearance from her husband, Jacob Neeley, dressed as Dan Humphrey, dipping his wife for a kiss. This delightful interaction further captivated fans, with comments like “soooo good” and “this is so so perfect ! !” pouring in.
While Mayci generally tends to avoid some of the more intense conflicts on The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, her portrayal of Serena showed a fun, confident side, perfectly in line with the character’s adventurous spirit.
Anticipation Builds for Season 3 of ‘The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives’
These viral Halloween costumes couldn’t have come at a better time, fueling fan excitement for the upcoming Season 3 of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives. The new season is set to drop on Thursday, November 13, exclusively on Hulu Press.
The trailer for Season 3 promises an abundance of drama. Beyond their grilling of Marciano Brunette, Mayci Neeley and Mikayla Matthews will undoubtedly be at the center of new secrets and confrontations. Mikayla even decided to temporarily pause her feud with co-star Whitney Leavitt for the Halloween festivities, leaving fans to wonder if Blair Waldorf would approve of such a truce.
In addition to Mayci Neeley and Mikayla Matthews, the teaser confirms the return of several other fan-favorite cast members, ensuring a season packed with intriguing storylines. The confirmed returning cast includes:
- Taylor Frankie Paul
- Jessi Ngatikaura
- Demi Engemann
- Whitney Leavitt
- Jennifer Affleck
- Layla Taylor
- Miranda McWhorter
As the premiere date draws closer, Mayci and Mikayla have certainly set the stage, reminding fans of their charismatic personalities and knack for capturing the internet’s attention. Whether embodying Upper East Side socialites or navigating the complexities of their reality show, these besties continue to deliver captivating content.
