Influencer Maggie Thurmon has subtly, yet directly, indicated that her ex-boyfriend, singer Benson Boone, was unfaithful during their year-and-a-half-long relationship, sparking widespread fan speculation and opening a new chapter in their public narrative.
The public split between internet personality Maggie Thurmon and “Beautiful Things” singer Benson Boone has taken a dramatic turn, with Thurmon seemingly alleging infidelity on Boone’s part. What began as rumors of a breakup escalated quickly after Thurmon’s cryptic social media activity, leaving fans of the once-beloved couple searching for answers.
The Subtle Accusation: A TikTok and a Telling Comment
The core of the allegations stems from a since-deleted TikTok video posted by Maggie Thurmon, the 23-year-old influencer with over 5 million followers. In the video, Thurmon lip-synced to an audio clip from the TV show The Office where a character asks, “Remember how it felt when he cheated on you?” to which the response is, “Which time?”
While the video itself was ambiguous, a subsequent interaction left little room for doubt. According to screenshots widely shared online, a user commented on the video, “bro if benson cheated i will turn this car right around.” Thurmon’s direct reply, “Put your blinker on babe,” was interpreted by many as a clear confirmation of cheating allegations, as reported by AOL and Distractify.
Shortly after these posts gained traction, Thurmon deleted the TikTok. She later posted a comment on a different TikTok, expressing her discomfort with the public nature of the situation: “I got overwhelmed. I’ve always been a more private online person, tonight I remembered why. Thank you to everyone who was sending love, I appreciate yall so much.❤️”
The Road to a Split: Hints from Both Sides
The couple’s split was first rumored in September, approximately a month before Thurmon’s TikTok. Singer Benson Boone himself fueled speculation during an emotional speech at a Nashville tour stop. He stated, “Sometimes people leave your life. Whether it’s the right thing or the wrong thing — and it is always hard, always, every single time,” as noted by People. This statement led several outlets to report on their separation shortly after.
Thurmon also opened up about her struggles post-breakup. In a September 29 post to her book club Instagram account, she admitted to having “disappeared” and teased that “something happened” that caused her to go offline. She described feeling “overthinking” and sad, unable to focus on reading due to “things currently making me sad, the things I’m overthinking, the things I, like, can’t get out of my brain.” This candid admission resonated with many of her followers, who interpreted it as a direct reference to the end of her relationship with Boone.
A Timeline of Their Relationship
Maggie Thurmon and Benson Boone’s romance was a prominent fixture in the influencer and music scenes for about a year and a half. Their public relationship unfolded as follows:
- March 2024: First spotted together at Elton John’s AIDS Foundation Academy Awards viewing party.
- Months Later: Officially debuted their relationship on Instagram.
- July 2024: Attended the premiere of Twisters as a couple.
- September 2024: Walked the VMAs red carpet together.
- 2025 Grammys: Thurmon was present for Boone’s viral performance, which included a striptease assist from Heidi Klum and Nikki Glaser.
- May 2025: Thurmon supported Boone as he performed as the musical guest on Saturday Night Live, appearing in photos he shared on Instagram.
- September 2025: Their split was first reported.
Fan Reactions and the ‘Touring Musician’ Stereotype
The news of the alleged cheating sparked significant discussion within fan communities. On platforms like Reddit, some users expressed dismay, while others leaned into the stereotype of infidelity among touring musicians. One user commented, “I swear to god there needs to be some basic orientation class before you can date a touring musician. Being on the road is such a uniquely weird psychological experience where you’re basically living apart from the rest of the world, and almost nobody handles it well,” according to Distractify. Another user even made light of Boone’s signature backflip, playfully suggesting it was a “classic frat bro move.”
While fan theories and speculation abound, representatives for Benson Boone have not publicly commented on the allegations. Maggie Thurmon’s representatives have also not responded to requests for comment, maintaining a degree of privacy around the sensitive topic.
Looking Ahead: The Aftermath of Allegations
The revelation of alleged infidelity adds a complex layer to the breakup of Maggie Thurmon and Benson Boone. For a fan community that followed their romance closely, this development transforms their story from a simple parting of ways into a more dramatic and poignant narrative. While details remain officially unconfirmed by either party, Thurmon’s powerful social media hints have undeniably shaped the public’s perception of the split, prompting widespread discussion and sympathy for the influencer.
