**James Taylor, the six-time Grammy-winning legend, reveals his personal top five songs from his iconic discography, offering fans a rare glimpse into the emotional and artistic depth of his most treasured works.**
When James Taylor, the legendary singer-songwriter behind timeless hits like “Fire and Rain” and “You’ve Got a Friend,” appeared on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert in early February 2026, he was asked a question that seemed simple yet was anything but: “What are James Taylor’s top five James Taylor songs?” For an artist with a career spanning over five decades and dozens of chart-topping tracks, the choice was deeply personal—and revealing.
Stefani Reynolds/AFP via Getty
The Songs That Made the Cut — and Why They Matter
- “Mean Old Man”: Taylor revealed that Paul McCartney once reached out to him to praise this song, even admitting he’d bought the entire album because of it. “That’s got to go in there,” Taylor told Colbert, highlighting the deep validation of having a Beatle acknowledge his work.
- “Millworker”: A standout from the 1979 album Working, this song tells the heartbreaking tale of a woman laboring in a steel mill. It became a favorite of Bruce Springsteen, who performed it in concert—another moment of peer admiration that shaped Taylor’s choices.
- “Sweet Baby James”: The 1970 title track from Taylor’s breakthrough album. A gentle lullaby dedicated to his nephew, it became an emblem of the singer-songwriter movement and launched him to stardom.
- “God Have Mercy on the Frozen Man”: From 1991’s New Moon Shine, this song earned praise from Bob Dylan after they performed together at Harlem’s Apollo Theater. Dylan’s appreciation elevated its significance in Taylor’s eyes.
- “Carolina in My Mind”: Released in 1968, this song remains one of his most beloved, later rerecorded for his greatest hits. It reflected his roots and became a permanent part of his live repertoire.
Why This List Shows a Life Story
Taylor’s selections are more than just hits—they are landmarks. “Sweet Baby James” marks his rise as a voice of the folk-rock generation, while songs like “Millworker” demonstrate his growth as a storyteller and social observer. Each title on his list is tied not just to musical success, but to personal memories, peer validation, and even messages he needed to share at different stages of his life.
His choice to highlight songs praised by McCartney, Springsteen, and Dylan—three of rock and folk’s most iconic figures—reveals how respect from fellow artists can shape a musician’s own view of their work.
Kevin Dietsch/Getty
Fan Reactions and Legacy
The reaction on social media was immediate and emotional. Fans praised Taylor’s humility and choice of deep-cut favorites like “God Have Mercy on the Frozen Man,” which often get overshadowed in live setlists.
His 1991 album, New Moon Shine was quietly influential—winning a Grammy for Best Pop Album—but seldom gets the spotlight. Highlighting it in front of millions on national TV brought new appreciation to an era some younger fans may have missed.
John Shearer/Getty
Why This Moment Matters
At 77, Taylor is in a reflective phase of his career. His 2020 album American Standard reinterpreted classic tunes, while his recent shows have emphasized story, not just sound. By sharing this list, he lets fans see what he values beyond the radio hits—the songs that carry memories, legacy, and the quiet validation of legends.
And by doing so not in a memoir or behind-the-scenes documentary, but live on Colbert’s widely watched platform, he connects directly with a global audience. It’s a gift—a playlist shaped not by sales or fame, but by music that changed his path.
For more of the fastest, most insightful coverage of music, film, and entertainment, read onlytrustedinfo.com.
