With the fantasy football season hitting its critical Week 9 juncture, securing a reliable backup running back, often called a ‘handcuff,’ can be the difference between a playoff push and an early exit. Injuries are inevitable, and understanding who’s next in line for a significant workload is paramount for any championship contender.
As the leaves turn and the calendar prepares to flip to November, the 2024 fantasy football season has reached its midway point. For many, playoff aspirations are still within reach, while others face a desperate scramble. This is the time when astute fantasy managers reflect on draft day decisions, assess player performance, and, most importantly, prepare for the unpredictable nature of the game: injuries and bye weeks. The running back position, known for its high-impact physicality, becomes increasingly vital to manage through strategic handcuffing.
A well-placed handcuff isn’t just insurance; it’s a potential league-winner. When a starting running back goes down, their understudy can instantly leap into a high-volume role, transforming from a bench stash to a weekly starter. Our comprehensive breakdown for Week 9 dives into the top backup running backs based on their potential to seize a lead role and deliver significant fantasy points.
Top 10 Backup Running Backs for Week 9
Here’s how we rank the crucial backup running backs heading into Week 9, factoring in their current roles, potential for increased touches, and the injury history of their respective starters. This list prioritizes immediate impact and high-upside opportunities.
- David Montgomery (Lions): Though sometimes viewed as a starter in his own right, David Montgomery remains technically behind Jahmyr Gibbs in the Lions’ pecking order. He consistently plays under 45% of snaps in games where both are active. However, Montgomery’s goal-line prowess and consistent involvement make him a low-end RB2/RB3 with standalone value. Should Gibbs face a sideline stint, Montgomery would instantly vault into unquestioned RB1 territory, making him the top handcuff to own.
- Zach Charbonnet (Seahawks): The Seattle backfield dynamic has been shifting, with Zach Charbonnet even outsnapping Kenneth Walker III in recent weeks. Despite less yardage than Walker, Charbonnet has shown a knack for finding the end zone, tallying five touchdowns on the season. While the trend continues, Charbonnet is a touchdown-dependent RB3, but his ceiling climbs significantly to a top-12 back if Walker were sidelined, confirming his strong handcuff appeal as highlighted in previous rankings by Yahoo Sports.
- RJ Harvey (Broncos): A recent standout, RJ Harvey has flashed big-play potential. He delivered his second major fantasy performance in Week 8, converting eight touches into 51 yards and three touchdowns. Given J.K. Dobbins’ extensive injury history, Harvey is poised for a significant role should Dobbins miss time. Currently a RB3/flex option, his upside is substantial.
- Chuba Hubbard (Panthers): Chuba Hubbard has seen a shift in his role in Carolina, seemingly ceding lead-back duties to Rico Dowdle. His efficiency has dipped, averaging less than three yards per carry over the last two weeks. However, Hubbard’s prior lead-back experience and familiarity with the offense mean he remains a valuable handcuff. Should Dowdle falter or get injured, Hubbard would quickly regain a prominent workload. This shift in the Carolina backfield has been a point of discussion among fantasy analysts, with Dowdle’s recent surge noted across major sports outlets like CBS Sports.
- Rachaad White (Buccaneers): With Bucky Irving on the sidelines due to injury, Rachaad White has stepped up admirably in the lead role for the Buccaneers. While his efficiency has wavered with the team’s struggles, White is a pass-catching asset who remains a must-start option while Irving is out. Even upon Irving’s return, White could maintain flex appeal due to his receiving work. There have even been whispers in the fan community about a potential trade for White if Tampa Bay believes their younger backs, like Sean Tucker, could handle the load, as speculated by analysts in previous weeks.
- Tyler Allgeier (Falcons): A consistent fixture on handcuff lists, Tyler Allgeier remains the clear backup to superstar Bijan Robinson. Despite Robinson’s presence, Allgeier has carved out a productive role, scoring touchdowns in three of his last five games. His 1,000-yard rushing season in 2023 demonstrates his capability to handle a full workload. Allgeier offers standalone flex value and would be a locked-in top-20 fantasy RB if Robinson were ever unavailable.
- Bhayshul Tuten (Jaguars): Emerging as the definitive No. 2 back in Jacksonville after the Tank Bigsby trade, Bhayshul Tuten has yet to see his role expand significantly behind Travis Etienne Jr. Despite limited usage, Tuten has impressed with his impact plays. He’s currently a volatile flex option, but an injury to Etienne would immediately elevate Tuten to a fantasy starter with high upside.
- Brian Robinson Jr. (49ers): Though not a primary flex option in his current capacity, Brian Robinson Jr. offers immense upside if Christian McCaffrey were to get injured. Just a year removed from an RB21 finish with over 1,100 scrimmage yards and nine touchdowns, Robinson’s potential in Kyle Shanahan’s run-heavy scheme cannot be overstated. His experience and previous production make him a top-tier handcuff.
- Blake Corum (Rams): The Rams’ backfield has been dominated by Kyren Williams’ near 90% snap share, but Blake Corum remains the lone other back seeing touches. Corum played a season-high 34% of snaps in Week 7, showcasing his readiness. Being the clear No. 2 in a Sean McVay offense that maximizes running back production gives Corum significant fantasy value. He’s a borderline flex option in favorable matchups and a must-roster handcuff in all formats.
- Tyjae Spears (Titans): The Titans’ backfield situation is intriguing, especially with whispers of Tony Pollard potentially being a trade candidate. If Pollard were moved, Tyjae Spears has already proven his ability to excel as a starter, with impressive performances during last season’s fantasy playoffs. His explosive Week 15 (92 yards, 2 TDs), Week 16 (66 yards, 2 TDs), and Week 17 (103 yards) demonstrate his potential. If Pollard stays, Spears is a risky flex play, but his upside if given the lead role is undeniable.
Other Key Backup Running Backs to Monitor
Beyond the top ten, several other running backs deserve attention due to their unique situations, recent performance, or high-upside potential. Staying ahead on these players can provide a critical advantage.
High-Upside Stashes and Emerging Talents
- Jaylen Warren (Steelers): While Najee Harris has been strong, Jaylen Warren remains a phenomenal handcuff. He’s a receiving threat, and in games where the Steelers play from behind, he could see a significant target share, making him a strong acquisition, especially in PPR formats.
- Ray Davis (Bills): Ranked highly in earlier handcuff discussions, Ray Davis is the clear backup in Buffalo’s potent offense. He saw touches even in a blowout, indicating the team’s trust. His high-powered offensive environment means immediate fantasy relevance if James Cook were to miss time.
- Isaac Guerendo (49ers): With Jordan Mason battling a recurring shoulder injury, Isaac Guerendo has stepped into a more prominent role, as noted by ESPN. Given Christian McCaffrey’s “iffy at best” status at times, Guerendo could be thrust into a meaningful workload if Mason’s injury lingers or McCaffrey’s return is delayed. He’s a high-priority scoop from the waiver wire.
- Jaylen Wright (Dolphins): The Miami backfield, shared by De’Von Achane and Raheem Mostert, is known for its explosive plays but also its injury concerns for both starters. Jaylen Wright has looked impressive in limited touches, averaging 5.3 yards per carry. His athleticism makes him an intriguing stash with significant upside if an opportunity arises.
- Kendre Miller (Saints): Speculation around an Alvin Kamara trade has made Kendre Miller a compelling handcuff. If Kamara were to be moved, Miller would likely see a major increase in carries as the Saints assess his potential for the future.
Players with Injury Situations or Changing Roles
- Tyrone Tracy (Giants): Tyrone Tracy had a breakout performance but suffered a concussion, putting his Week 9 availability in doubt. This highlights the fluidity of backup roles and could push Devin Singletary into a short-term option, especially if the Giants continue their strong running game.
- Braelon Allen (Jets): The Jets’ disappointing season (2-6) has fueled discussions about giving younger players more opportunities. Braelon Allen could see additional carries late in the season to keep Breece Hall fresh for 2025. He’s an “upside backup with injuries” and a long-term stash.
- Ty Chandler (Vikings): Despite Aaron Jones’ heavy workload (92% of snaps, 100% of RB opportunities in a recent game), concerns about his ability to sustain that pace keep Ty Chandler relevant. If Jones breaks down, Chandler would be in line for a significant role in the Vikings’ offense.
- Justice Hill (Ravens): Often considered a “boring backup” by some, Justice Hill remains a valuable asset, particularly in PPR leagues due to his pass-catching ability. He’s a reliable option if any injury were to strike the Ravens’ backfield.
Navigating Trade Deadlines and Roster Shifts
The fantasy football landscape is constantly evolving, with trade deadlines and team strategy shifts heavily influencing player values. The rumors surrounding potential trades for players like Tony Pollard and even Alvin Kamara underscore the volatile nature of the running back position. These rumors are not just whispers; they represent real opportunities for backups like Tyjae Spears and Kendre Miller to ascend to lead roles, making them essential pickups before their situations clarify.
For dedicated fantasy enthusiasts, proactively acquiring these backup running backs isn’t merely about injury protection; it’s about anticipating market shifts and roster opportunities. The difference between a waiver wire claim and a championship run often comes down to who held the right handcuff at the right time. As Week 9 approaches, take the time to solidify your depth at running back. Your future fantasy success might just depend on it.
