The unexpected split between singer Benson Boone and actress Maggie Thurmon left fans reeling, but it was Thurmon’s cryptic social media posts, strongly implying infidelity with the phrase “put your blinker on babe,” that truly ignited a firestorm of speculation and sorrow among their devoted followers.
The world of pop music and social media was recently rocked by the dramatic breakup of former American Idol participant and rising star Benson Boone and actor Maggie Thurmon. What began as quiet speculation escalated quickly into a viral sensation after Thurmon took to TikTok, making strong implications that infidelity played a role in their separation. This deep dive explores their romance, the shocking allegations, and the fervent fan reactions that followed.
The Romance That Was: Benson and Maggie’s Journey
Before the rumors of betrayal, Benson Boone and Maggie Thurmon were, in the eyes of many fans, a quintessential young Hollywood couple. Their relationship spanned three years, blossoming as Boone’s fame soared, particularly after his success on American Idol and hits like “Beautiful Things.” They made their relationship public at Elton John’s AIDS Foundation Academy Awards viewing party in March 2024, becoming a fixture at high-profile events like the Grammy Awards and Saturday Night Live.
Despite Boone’s burgeoning celebrity, the couple appeared happy and mutually devoted, leading many to believe in their lasting love story. Fans often described them as going “together like peanut butter and jelly,” highlighting the perceived strength and sweetness of their bond.
When the Unfollowing Began: Initial Breakup Speculation
The first hints of trouble in paradise emerged around September 2025. Eagle-eyed fans noticed that Benson Boone and Maggie Thurmon had unfollowed each other on Instagram, a modern-day indicator of a relationship’s end. This digital distancing was quickly picked up by media outlets, with TMZ confirming their split that same month, although the exact reason remained shrouded in mystery.
Further adding to the public’s concern, Boone himself seemed to address the breakup during his American Heart Tour performance in Nashville on September 9. Before singing “In The Stars,” he delivered a visibly emotional speech about loss:
“Sometimes people leave your life. Whether it’s the right thing or the wrong thing. And it is always hard, always, every single time. And it sucks. And it sucks to sit in it, and it sucks to be sad about it, and it sucks to feel that so hard sometimes. But it’s okay, it’s life. It happens. And as terrible as it is, there’s always something or someone who can pull you out of it.”
This heartfelt confession, made just days before the breakup went public, resonated deeply with fans, fueling speculation about the nature of their separation.
Maggie Thurmon’s Cryptic Confessions: “Which Time?” and “Put Your Blinker On Babe”
The breakup moved from speculation to apparent confirmation of infidelity when Maggie Thurmon posted a now-deleted TikTok video in mid-October 2025. In the video, Thurmon lip-synced to a sound clip where one voice asks, “Remember how it felt when he cheated on you, though?” and the response is, “Which time?” This pointed audio choice, weeks after their reported split, immediately sparked intense discussion among her followers.
The situation intensified in the comments section. When a fan wrote, “Bro if Benson cheated I will turn this car right around,” Thurmon’s succinct and impactful reply — “Put your blinker on babe” — was widely interpreted as a direct confirmation of Boone’s alleged infidelity. This exchange was caught by several outlets, including Parade, before the TikTok was taken down.
The ensuing online chatter led Thurmon to comment on an older TikTok from October 6, explaining her decision to remove the video: “I got overwhelmed. I’ve always been a more private online person, tonight I remembered why. Thank you to everyone who was sending love, I appreciate yall so much.❤.” This indicated the immense pressure she felt from the public spotlight on her personal life.
The Kylee Anderson Connection: A Potential Third Party?
Amidst the swirling rumors, another name emerged: Kylee Anderson, a singer and childhood friend of Benson Boone from Utah. Following Boone and Thurmon’s mutual unfollowing on Instagram, Anderson was also reportedly unfollowed by both, drawing attention to her. The speculation intensified due to a song Anderson released in August 2025 titled “Benny.”
The song’s lyrics describe falling in love with a best friend and sharing a romantic moment. Furthermore, Anderson allegedly commented on the song, stating, “My experience with my best friend who i fell in love with and he ended up getting a gf and expected me to be friends with her.” This statement led many fans to connect the dots, suggesting Anderson might have been involved in the couple’s breakup. It’s crucial to remember that these are unconfirmed allegations based on internet speculation, as neither Anderson nor Boone has directly addressed them.
Fan Reactions and the “Touring Musician” Trope
The fan community reacted with a mix of heartbreak, humor, and cynicism. While many who had invested emotionally in the Benson and Maggie love story were crushed, others on platforms like Reddit took a more jaded view.
Discussions online often revolved around the perceived challenges of dating touring musicians. One Reddit user commented, “I swear to god there needs to be some basic orientation class before you can date a touring musician. Being on the road is such a uniquely weird psychological experience where you’re basically living apart from the rest of the world, and almost nobody handles it well.” This sentiment highlights a common trope in the entertainment industry regarding infidelity among artists on the road. The public nature of a musician’s lifestyle often leads to heightened perceptions, if not actual instances, of such issues, as noted by Distractify.
Despite the sadness, Maggie’s dry and direct “put your blinker on babe” response earned her a degree of admiration and even some giggles from fans who appreciated her sense of humor in a difficult situation.
What Lies Ahead for Benson and Maggie?
As of now, the allegations of cheating remain unconfirmed by Benson Boone himself. Maggie Thurmon’s social media activity has been the primary source of these strong implications. Boone’s emotional speech subtly acknowledged the pain of a breakup without delving into specifics.
While the full truth behind the split remains elusive to the public, the narrative constructed through social media and fan discussions paints a vivid picture of a relationship that ended under a cloud of alleged infidelity. As both artists move forward in their careers, the impact of this highly publicized breakup will undoubtedly continue to be a topic of discussion among their dedicated fanbases.
