The love story of Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes, forged amidst intense public scrutiny and a high-profile exit from Good Morning America, has culminated in a 2025 engagement, marking a significant milestone in their journey from controversial romance to committed partners.
The relationship between former Good Morning America co-hosts Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes has been anything but conventional. After their romance sparked significant media attention in late 2022, leading to their departure from GMA3, the couple has openly navigated public scrutiny, eventually confirming their engagement in October 2025. This deep dive explores their candid discussions about commitment, the evolution of their relationship, and the path that led them to this significant milestone.
The Genesis of a High-Profile Romance
The initial revelation of Robach and Holmes’ relationship sent shockwaves through the media landscape. In November 2022, they were photographed together on multiple occasions, sparking rumors as both were still legally married to other people. Robach was with ex-husband Andrew Shue, while Holmes was with ex-wife Marilee Fiebig. The ensuing scandal prompted their removal from their roles at GMA3, thrusting their personal lives into the public eye.
Despite the controversial start, the couple chose to address their relationship head-on. Nearly a year after their exit from ABC, they launched their “Amy & T.J.” podcast. This platform became their primary avenue for discussing their experiences, feelings, and the progression of their romance, offering fans an unfiltered look into their journey.
Evolving Views on Marriage: From ‘Under Consideration’ to ‘Coming’
Before their engagement, Robach and Holmes had several frank discussions on their podcast about the prospect of marriage, revealing a nuanced and evolving perspective on commitment.
December 2023: Early Intentions and Considerations
In December 2023, Robach shared that marriage was “under consideration.” She clarified their intentions, stating, “We did not enter this relationship for fun or for, ‘Let’s see what happens.’ We entered this relationship because we intended on spending our lives together.” While acknowledging a desire to spend her life with Holmes, she emphasized they weren’t “racing” towards the wedding aisle, as reported by Us Weekly.
Holmes humorously added to the conversation, stating he wanted to marry her “in part, because you’re 50 and I’m 46. And I’m very sick of introducing a 50-year-old woman as my girlfriend.”
April 2024: The Debate on Legal Commitment
In April 2024, the discussion continued with Robach admitting they were “still deciding” about a potential walk down the aisle. She differentiated between mental and emotional commitment and a legal bond. “Mentally, emotionally, we’ve absolutely agreed to commit to each other. … We haven’t figured the marriage thing out yet,” Robach revealed on their podcast, as detailed by People. She expressed a desire for a “life partner” and to eventually live with Holmes.
Robach also touched upon the idea of marriage as a “false security blanket,” suggesting that legal ties can make it harder to walk away during tough times. Holmes countered, questioning if being with someone “because it’s hard to get away from you” was truly desirable. Ultimately, they both agreed that an un-legalized commitment could be seen as even stronger, as partners choose each other daily without any legal obligation.
December 2024: A Decision is Made
By December 2024, the tone had shifted significantly. Robach revealed her desire for a fall wedding, and Holmes hinted at an impending proposal, seeing them as husband and wife “sooner rather than later.” He asserted that a “decision has been made” about their lifelong commitment. “When we are getting married, that’s going to be a byproduct of what’s happening. And it’s coming,” he explained, emphasizing the difference between simply talking about marriage and planning a wedding.
The Engagement Announcement: October 2025
The long-anticipated news finally arrived in October 2025. On an episode of their “Amy & T.J.” podcast, the couple officially announced their engagement. “We are sharing with all of you that we are engaged and we’ve been engaged for just about a month now,” Robach shared, with Holmes adding, “We wanted to let you all know before anybody else was able to. We’ve learned that lesson, I guess, in the past about our relationship.” This announcement was first reported by Us Weekly.
Interestingly, Robach had been wearing her engagement ring openly at football stadiums for weeks prior to the announcement, yet it went largely unnoticed. This detail highlights a shift in public perception, perhaps signaling a growing acceptance or simply a respect for their privacy as they navigated their personal journey.
What’s Next for the Engaged Couple?
With an engagement now public, attention turns to wedding plans. Robach has expressed a desire for a small, intimate gathering, potentially even an elopement in Vegas with a justice of the peace. This vision reflects a desire for a personal celebration, far from the public spectacle that marked the beginning of their romance.
A fascinating twist in their story involves their former spouses. Reports suggest that Robach’s ex-husband, Andrew Shue, and Holmes’ ex-wife, Marilee Fiebig, have also begun a romance. This unexpected development adds another layer to their already unique narrative, underscoring how relationships can intertwine in unforeseen ways.
A Love Story Redefined
The journey of Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes is a testament to finding love and commitment under extraordinary circumstances. From the initial scandal that cost them their high-profile careers to their candid podcast discussions and eventual engagement, they have continually redefined their relationship on their own terms. Their story, rich with challenges and unwavering commitment, offers a compelling narrative for fans and observers alike, proving that even in the brightest spotlight, love can find a way to thrive.
