There’s no escaping the past for Tori Spelling and Brian Austin Green.
In PEOPLE’s first look at the former Beverly Hills, 90210 stars’ reunion on the May 11 episode of The $100,000 Pyramid, the pair tease each other about the first time they had sex.
After introducing Spelling on the game show, host Michael Strahan says, “You and Brian, you’ve known each other.”
“Way too long,” she interrupts, and Strahan, 53, adds, “But I heard he forgot something that happened between you two.”
“Oh geez,” Green, 51, responds before Spelling, 51, explains that he couldn’t remember one detail from their past.
Related: Tori Spelling Says She Feels Like a ‘Stupid Girl’ Reminding Brian Austin Green of the First Time They Had Sex
“Yes, recently on my podcast misSPELLING, we did talk about when we were young teenagers and we hooked up, and he couldn’t remember exactly the first time we hooked up,” recalls.
“I don’t remember that story at all, which is crazy,” the actor admits, to which Spelling jokes, “Which means I was really memorable.”
“I think she’s making this up,” Green concludes but Strahan insists, “That’s her story and she’s sticking to it.”
Disney/Christopher Willard
Brian Austin Green on ‘The $100,000 Pyramid’
Related: Tori Spelling Reunites with Beverly Hills, 90210 Costars Brian Austin Green and Ian Ziering: ‘Great Day with These 2’
Green previously revealed on the Nov. 5 episode of her misSPELLING podcast that he couldn’t recall their first hookup.
During a trip to Disneyland alongside their 90210 costars, Spelling recalled that she and Green — who were seeing each other at the time — spent the entire day fighting.
“We used to have those huge blowout fights for a lot,” Green said. “And I think a lot of that was attraction and a lot of that was really coming of age in it all.”
As Spelling continued the story, the television personality teased that the argument ended in the two having sex for the first time, but Green insisted that he didn’t remember those details.
The PEOPLE App is now available in the Apple App Store! Download it now for the most binge-worthy celeb content, exclusive video clips, astrology updates and more!
Ron Davis/Getty
From left: Tori Spelling and Brian Austin Green in 1992
Related: Tori Spelling Opens Up About Brian Austin Green Inspiring Her to Join Dancing with the Stars (Exclusive)
“I was like, ‘Why are you always getting mad? Why are you why are we always fighting?’” the actress said. “And you said, ‘Have you ever thought that maybe I fight with you because I love you?’”
“Yeah, and you were probably saying ‘I love you’ like we’re sister, brother, like, friends,” she added. “And I was like, ‘He said I love you.’ And then we started kissing.”
“Wait, what? I love this story,” Green joked. “I feel I’m hearing a story of you and someone else right now.”
“I feel like such a stupid girl right now!” Spelling then told him.
Though Green and Spelling shared a romantic connection in the past, both stars moved on to different relationships. Spelling ended up marrying Dean McDermott in May 2006, but they have since split and filed for divorce. Meanwhile, Green was married to Megan Fox from 2010 to 2021 and is now engaged to Sharna Burgess.
Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.
The $100,000 Pyramid airs Sundays at 10 p.m. ET on ABC.
Read the original article on People
