Before her memorable alien abduction farewell, Kate McKinnon, one of Saturday Night Live’s longest-serving female cast members, recently revealed a far more audacious original pitch for her final episode: a ‘goodbye tonguing’ featuring her character Sheila Sovage kissing every cast member. Ultimately, the more ‘meaningful’ Colleen Rafferty alien sketch was chosen, leaving fans to ponder the hilarious alternate history.
For a decade, from 2012 to 2022, Kate McKinnon was a cornerstone of Saturday Night Live, captivating audiences with her extraordinary range, impeccable comedic timing, and unforgettable characters. Her departure in 2022 was an emotional moment for both McKinnon and devoted fans, marked by a poignant final sketch featuring her beloved alien abductee, Colleen Rafferty. However, McKinnon recently unveiled a wildly different, and far more risqué, original idea for her farewell that almost made it to air.
The Unseen Farewell: A ‘Goodbye Tonguing’
During an appearance on Amy Poehler’s Good Hang podcast, McKinnon spilled the details of her initial, eyebrow-raising pitch. She envisioned bringing back her character Sheila Sovage, the unkempt barfly known for her aggressive displays of affection. The concept was simple yet shocking: Sheila would “tongue every single person in the cast in a line.”
Poehler, an SNL alum herself from 2001 to 2008, reacted with laughter, perfectly dubbing the proposed send-off a “goodbye tonguing.” McKinnon recounted the moment with characteristic humor, noting, “So everyone narrowly missed sucking my face.” The image of such a chaotic and uninhibited farewell sketch undoubtedly sparks both laughter and a sense of ‘what if’ among fans who adore McKinnon’s boundary-pushing comedy.
From Bold Kissing to Celestial Departure: Why the Change?
While the idea of Sheila Sovage’s grand, sloppy goodbye was undeniably hilarious, McKinnon ultimately decided against it. Her primary reason was a desire for something more profound. She explained that she felt “the alien thing was a little more meaningful and had a better tone,” which led to the selection of the now-iconic Colleen Rafferty sketch. This decision highlights McKinnon’s thoughtful approach to her craft, even when presented with a wildly comedic alternative.
Beyond artistic considerations, practical constraints also played a role in shelving the “goodbye tonguing” concept. In August 2022, McKinnon confirmed to Entertainment Weekly that lingering COVID-19 restrictions at the time would have made such a close-contact sketch unfeasible. This sheds light on the unseen challenges performers and writers faced during the pandemic, often impacting creative choices for live television.
The Beloved Colleen Rafferty Farewell
Instead of Sheila Sovage, fans witnessed the final chapter of Colleen Rafferty, the character perpetually recounting bizarre and unsettling alien encounters while her fellow abductees describe blissful, transcendent experiences. In McKinnon’s farewell sketch, Colleen finally accepts her fate, opting to leave Earth permanently with the extraterrestrial beings.
The scene was deeply moving, as McKinnon, appearing to hold back tears, delivered Colleen’s final lines: “Well, Earth, I love ya. Thanks for letting me stay a while.” She waved goodbye as she boarded the spaceship, creating a surprisingly emotional and memorable exit that perfectly encapsulated her unique brand of comedy and heartfelt performance. This heartfelt goodbye resonated deeply with the fan community, becoming an instant classic among SNL departures.
Will Heath/NBC via Getty
Kate McKinnon hosts ‘Saturday Night Live’ in 2023
A Decade of Laughter and Unmatched Legacy
During her ten-year run on SNL, Kate McKinnon not only entertained millions but also carved out a significant place in the show’s history. When she departed, she held the record for the longest-serving woman in the cast, a testament to her enduring popularity and versatility. Her ability to embody a vast array of characters, from uncanny impressions of political figures like Hillary Clinton and Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg to quirky original creations, earned her widespread critical acclaim.
McKinnon’s talent was formally recognized with numerous accolades. She received nine Emmy nominations during her tenure, winning two back-to-back in 2016 and 2017 for Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Comedy Series. Her awards cemented her status as one of the most celebrated performers in SNL’s modern era.
The Difficult Decision and Life After SNL
Leaving a show that had been “everything” to her was not an easy decision for McKinnon. She shared with Kelly Ripa on Live With Kelly and Ryan that she “thought about it for a very long time, and it was very, very hard.” Ultimately, the demands of live television took their toll. As she candidly expressed, “my body was tired, and I felt like it was time.” Her departure marked the end of an era for many fans, but also opened new doors for the beloved comedian.
Since her departure from the main cast, McKinnon has continued to thrive. She made a popular return to host SNL in 2023, proving her lasting connection to the show. Her post-SNL career has also seen her take on prominent roles in major films, including the critically acclaimed Barbie and The Roses, further establishing her as a versatile talent beyond the sketch comedy stage.
A Fan’s Reflection on a Nearly Different Farewell
Kate McKinnon’s revelation of her original “goodbye tonguing” pitch offers a fascinating glimpse into the creative process behind SNL’s iconic farewells. While the Colleen Rafferty sketch delivered a perfect blend of humor and pathos, the thought of a raucous Sheila Sovage exit adds another layer to McKinnon’s legend. It’s a testament to her fearless comedic spirit that such a bold idea was even conceived.
For fans, this insight only deepens their appreciation for McKinnon’s unique contributions to Saturday Night Live. Her ability to make audiences laugh, cry, and even squirm with discomfort is precisely why she remains a cherished figure in comedy. Whether it was an emotional alien abduction or a scandalous barfly kiss, Kate McKinnon’s farewell would undoubtedly have been unforgettable, a true reflection of her unparalleled talent.
