Amidst the NFL midseason awards frenzy, we delve into Jonathan Taylor’s compelling MVP case, examining his historic 2021 performance, analyst predictions for his resurgence, and the challenges of a running back winning the league’s top individual honor. Plus, a comprehensive look at other key midseason surprises, disappointments, and standout performances across the league.
As the NFL season hits its stride and Thanksgiving approaches, the conversations around individual excellence intensify. Midseason awards are being handed out, and every stellar performance sparks debate among fans and analysts alike. At the heart of many of these discussions is the Indianapolis Colts’ dynamic running back, Jonathan Taylor, whose MVP potential has been a recurring theme.
Jonathan Taylor’s Enduring MVP Case
Jonathan Taylor’s MVP candidacy first took flight during his sensational 2021 season. After being lauded as a first-round worthy prospect before the 2020 NFL Draft, where he was ultimately selected in the second round by the Colts, he quickly proved his doubters wrong. His rookie campaign saw him rampage down the stretch, averaging 123.5 rushing yards per game over his final six regular-season contests, scoring eight total touchdowns. This elite production translated into a dominant second year.
In Week 11 of 2021, Taylor erupted for five touchdowns in a crucial 41-15 win over the Bills, leading the NFL with 15 total scores and 1,444 scrimmage yards. His performance anchored the Colts’ turnaround from an 0-3 start to a 6-5 record, with Taylor rushing for 951 yards and 13 touchdowns in an eight-game span. He even tied the single-season NFL record for most consecutive games with 100-plus scrimmage yards and one-plus rushing touchdown (eight), a record previously set by MVP winner LaDainian Tomlinson, as reported by NFL.com. This blend of power and speed, coupled with his ability to carry a team, squarely placed him in the MVP conversation, despite running backs rarely winning the award in the modern era.
Looking ahead, analysts continue to see MVP potential in Taylor. Despite battling multiple injuries that caused him to miss 13 games across the 2022 and 2023 seasons, NFL.com’s Eric Edholm believes Taylor is a more realistic MVP candidate for the Colts in 2024 than quarterback Anthony Richardson. Edholm expressed faith that Taylor will “revert back to the production he put up in years 1 and 2 of his pro career,” highlighting his importance as the team’s unquestioned workhorse. The level of threat posed by the Indianapolis offense hinges significantly on the health and tandem play of both Richardson and Taylor, with Taylor’s ability to stay on the field being paramount for offensive coordinator Shane Steichen’s plans to flourish.
As Yahoo Sports noted in their recent midseason awards discussion, the question, “Can Jonathan Taylor win MVP?” remains a compelling one, reflecting continued belief in his top-tier talent and potential impact for the Colts. His resurgence could be a key factor in the team’s postseason aspirations, especially with his track record of performing better with increased usage.
Midseason Awards: Reflecting on the First Half
Beyond the MVP race, the NFL midseason provides an opportunity to reflect on unexpected stories and stellar performances. NFL.com’s Jeffri Chadiha and the Yahoo Sports team have weighed in on some of the season’s most notable developments:
Looking Back: Surprises and Standouts
- Biggest Surprise: Sam Darnold, Minnesota Vikings. Darnold’s journey from a top-three pick to a journeyman backup was well-documented. However, his stunning resurgence, leading the Vikings to a 5-0 start and ranking among the league’s top five in passer rating, has been one of the feel-good stories of the season.
- Biggest Disappointment: New York Jets. After Super Bowl aspirations fueled by the acquisition of Aaron Rodgers, the Jets’ season quickly unraveled. Injuries, coaching changes, and a failure to capitalize on a strong defense led to a deeply frustrating first half.
- Best Offseason Acquisition: Derrick Henry, Baltimore Ravens. King Henry continues to defy age, leading the league in rushing yards (1,052), rushing touchdowns (11), and 100-yard efforts (five). His presence has transformed the Ravens’ offense, complementing Lamar Jackson’s MVP-level play.
- Best Coaching Job: Andy Reid, Kansas City Chiefs. Despite significant injuries to key offensive players like Rashee Rice and Marquise Brown, Reid has kept the Chiefs undefeated. His ability to adapt the offense, leaning more on the run and a strong defense, is a testament to his coaching prowess.
- Most Consequential Game of the First Half: Lions beat Vikings in Week 7. This 31-29 victory solidified the Lions as NFC front-runners, proving their mettle against an undefeated Vikings team and asserting dominance in what has become the NFL’s best division.
Other Stellar Midseason Performances
Many other players shone brightly through the first half, making their own cases for recognition:
- Chris Jones, Kansas City Chiefs DL: After a brief stint as an edge rusher, Jones returned to his dominant interior role, terrorizing opposing offenses with 3.5 sacks, a fumble recovery, a forced fumble, and a game-icing deflection in a crucial win against the Cowboys.
- Justin Herbert, Los Angeles Chargers QB: Herbert continues to be a highlight reel, showcasing his ability to orchestrate game-winning drives and deliver breathtaking plays. His 381 passing yards and 90 rushing yards in a single game mark a Super Bowl era first, demonstrating his dual-threat capabilities.
- Justin Jefferson, Minnesota Vikings WR: A certified stud, Jefferson continued his record-breaking pace, amassing 100-yard games at an incredible rate. His clutch performances were instrumental in turning the Vikings’ season around.
- Joe Mixon, Cincinnati Bengals RB: Mixon’s commanding 123 yards and two touchdowns on 30 carries against the Raiders demonstrated his role as the engine of the Bengals’ offense, allowing them to control time of possession and get back on track after a challenging start.
- Jalen Hurts, Philadelphia Eagles QB: Hurts’ growth as a true QB1, especially with the Eagles’ increased commitment to the run, has been pivotal. His three rushing touchdowns and 69 ground yards in a dominant win over the Saints highlighted his impact.
Looking Ahead: Second-Half Storylines and Predictions
The second half of the NFL season promises even more excitement, with several teams and individuals poised to make a significant impact:
Anticipated Turnarounds and Breakouts
- Overachieving Team with Staying Power: Washington Commanders. With rookie quarterback Jayden Daniels playing at an MVP level and a drastically improved defense, the Commanders have transformed into a serious playoff contender, making them more than just a feel-good story.
- Underachieving Team Most Likely to Turn Around: Cincinnati Bengals. Despite a frustrating start, the Bengals possess immense talent. With Joe Burrow leading the charge and a defense getting healthier, they are capable of a strong second-half surge, much like their 2022 campaign.
- Top Breakout Candidate: Marvin Harrison Jr., Arizona Cardinals. The highly touted rookie receiver has shown flashes of greatness. As he continues to gain experience, Harrison Jr. is expected to become an even more devastating weapon for the Cardinals as they push for a playoff spot.
- 2025 Free Agent Who Will Increase His Value: Tee Higgins, Cincinnati Bengals. Despite some injury setbacks, Higgins remains a legitimate WR1. His value to the Bengals’ offense is undeniable, and he’s poised for a lucrative contract in the upcoming offseason.
- Assistant Coach Who Will Emerge as Hottest Head-Coaching Candidate: Ben Johnson, Detroit Lions Offensive Coordinator. Johnson’s innovative offensive schemes have transformed the Lions into one of the league’s highest-scoring teams. His balanced approach and ability to maximize talent make him a highly coveted candidate for future head coaching vacancies.
Key Matchups on the Horizon
- Most Consequential Game of the Second Half: Chiefs at Bills (Week 11). This highly anticipated matchup could have significant implications for the AFC’s top seed and playoff bye. With both teams eyeing deep postseason runs, this game represents a critical test.
The Broader MVP Conversation
While Jonathan Taylor’s potential remains a tantalizing prospect, the MVP race is typically dominated by quarterbacks. As of Week 9 of the 2024 season, the top candidates for MVP often include:
- Josh Allen, Buffalo Bills QB
- Lamar Jackson, Baltimore Ravens QB
- Jared Goff, Detroit Lions QB
- Jayden Daniels, Washington Commanders QB
- Kyler Murray, Arizona Cardinals QB
The consistent presence of quarterbacks underscores the challenge for a running back to capture the league’s top individual honor in today’s NFL, a feat only achieved once in the last 14 seasons by Adrian Peterson in 2012.
Conclusion
The NFL midseason offers a fascinating snapshot of the league’s elite, its surprises, and its potential future stars. While Jonathan Taylor’s path to MVP is steep, his talent and impact on the Colts remain undeniable, making him one of the most intriguing players to watch. As the season progresses, the performances of these standout individuals and teams will undoubtedly shape the playoff picture and determine who ultimately takes home the coveted awards.
