onlyTrustedInfo.comonlyTrustedInfo.comonlyTrustedInfo.com
Notification
Font ResizerAa
  • News
  • Finance
  • Sports
  • Life
  • Entertainment
  • Tech
Reading: Federal appeals court blocks rule to make getting out of subscriptions easier
Share
onlyTrustedInfo.comonlyTrustedInfo.com
Font ResizerAa
  • News
  • Finance
  • Sports
  • Life
  • Entertainment
  • Tech
Search
  • News
  • Finance
  • Sports
  • Life
  • Entertainment
  • Tech
  • Advertise
  • Advertise
© 2025 OnlyTrustedInfo.com . All Rights Reserved.
Finance

Federal appeals court blocks rule to make getting out of subscriptions easier

Last updated: July 9, 2025 2:40 pm
Oliver James
Share
5 Min Read
Federal appeals court blocks rule to make getting out of subscriptions easier
SHARE

Canceling a subscription or membership service is often harder than signing up for one, with customers sometimes being forced to follow a maze of prompts, make a phone call, or even visit an office in person before they’re able to stop paying for something they don’t want.

Through a policy finalized last October, the Federal Trade Commission sought to address that problem with a so-called “click to cancel” rule that required companies to make canceling a subscription as simple as signing up, among other provisions meant to tackle things like auto-renewals that don’t first receive a customer’s informed consent. But that rule, which was set to go into effect July 14, was blocked by a federal appeals court this week over a procedural error, frustrating consumer advocates.

“Now we’re back to calling during business hours, endless hold music, or clicking through promo offers and other sludge to get to the cancellation page,” Neale Mahoney, an economist and professor at Stanford University who served in the Biden administration, wrote in a post on the social media website X. “The result will be higher switching costs, less competition, and ultimately higher prices and lower quality. That’s bad for markets and bad for consumers.”

This is a terrible economic outcome.

In my research (links below), I’ve shown that the subscription cancellation problem is big and leads to significant overpayments.

The click-to-cancel rule was poised to make meaningful progress on this problem.

Requiring firms to make it… https://t.co/0XN4oSIqlY

— Neale Mahoney (@nealemahoney) July 9, 2025

A three-judge panel with the US Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit said in its ruling that the FTC had missed a procedural step in the federal rule-making process: a preliminary regulatory analysis.

Though the FTC doesn’t have to issue such an analysis when the rule’s estimated annual impact on the US economy is less than $100 million — a threshold the FTC initially estimated the rule would not meet, according to the court’s ruling — an administrative judge had ruled it would. The FTC then proceeded to finalize the rule without a preliminary analysis, though it did conduct a final regulatory analysis, the court said.

“While we certainly do not endorse the use of unfair and deceptive practices in negative option marketing, the procedural deficiencies of the Commission’s rulemaking process are fatal here,” the judges wrote.

The FTC’s click-to-cancel rule, which would have made it much easier for consumers to get rid of unwanted online subscriptions, isn’t going into effect for one reason: the Biden FTC cut corners and didn’t follow the law. Process matters. https://t.co/t3xY5kX59i

— Mark Meador (@MeadorFTC) July 8, 2025

Writing on X, FTC Commissioner Mark Meador said that the “click-to-cancel” rule “isn’t going into effect for one reason: the Biden FTC cut corners and didn’t follow the law. Process matters.”

But Lina Khan, the FTC chair under the Biden administration, countered that the Trump administration’s FTC had “slow-walked it—and now a court has tossed it out, claiming industry didn’t get enough of a say.”

Over 16k Americans weighed in on the click-to-cancel rule, overwhelmingly supporting our effort to end subscription traps.

The rule was set to go into effect in May but this @FTC slow-walked it—and now a court has tossed it out, claiming industry didn’t get enough of a say.… https://t.co/SIY5nPDquu

— Lina Khan (@linamkhan) July 8, 2025

“Anyone frustrated by how difficult firms make it to cancel subscriptions can tell the @FTC commissioners to re-issue the rule and urge members of Congress to make it law,” Khan wrote on X.

The Groundwork Collaborative, a progressive economic justice advocacy group, also argued that lawmakers should now work to make the rule a reality.

“Congress should step up and ban these predatory subscription models that cheat consumers to restore fair pricing in America,” Executive Director Lindsay Owens said in a statement.

Emma Ockerman is a Senior Reporter for Yahoo Finance covering economic and labor issues in personal finance.

Sign up for the Mind Your Money newsletter

Click here for the latest personal finance news to help you with investing, paying off debt, buying a home, retirement, and more

Read the latest financial and business news from Yahoo Finance

You Might Also Like

Jack Mallers Named CEO Of New Bitcoin Powerhouse Twenty One Capital, Plans To Launch With 42,000 BTC

4 Simple Ways Trump’s $2.5B Bitcoin Deal Could Impact Everyone’s Wallet

Why Wolfspeed Stock Is Plummeting Today

Wix.com Issues Conservative Outlook Due To Macro Uncertainty, Increases Stock Buyback

Will AI replace Google on your iPhone? Apple thinks so. Here’s why.

Share This Article
Facebook X Copy Link Print
Share
Previous Article Lawsuit against Tesla includes claim the automaker hid data after fatal crash Lawsuit against Tesla includes claim the automaker hid data after fatal crash
Next Article 6 Secret Service agents suspended over conduct during attempted Trump assassination 6 Secret Service agents suspended over conduct during attempted Trump assassination

Latest News

Back-to-school sales tax holidays in these states will save you money
Back-to-school sales tax holidays in these states will save you money
Finance July 9, 2025
Nvidia has the best product, but its real edge is having the best customers
Nvidia has the best product, but its real edge is having the best customers
Finance July 9, 2025
What ex-South Korean leader Yoon faces following his new arrest over martial law
What ex-South Korean leader Yoon faces following his new arrest over martial law
News July 9, 2025
Challenge to Trump’s birthright citizenship order faces first major legal test after Supreme Court ruling
Challenge to Trump’s birthright citizenship order faces first major legal test after Supreme Court ruling
News July 9, 2025
//
  • About Us
  • Contact US
  • Privacy Policy
onlyTrustedInfo.comonlyTrustedInfo.com
© 2025 OnlyTrustedInfo.com . All Rights Reserved.