Cast iron skillets have long been a treasured tool in the kitchen. Valued by both collectors and home chefs for their quality craftsmanship and durability, some of these vintage pieces also happen to fetch high sums (think in the high hundreds to even thousands).
Whether their value stems from limited production runs, renowned manufacturers, or unique design features, here are over 10 vintage cast iron skillets that can sell for impressive amounts.
1. Griswold No. 13 Skillet (Early 1900s)
This skillet, with a 12.25-inch cooking surface, is among the largest made by renowned American manufacturer Griswold during its early years of production. Its size, combined with the early “ERIE” logo and spider heat ring, makes it extremely rare and valuable. With fewer than 200 still in circulation, collectors have been known to pay close to $2,000 for one.
2. Wapak’s Hollow Ware Skillet
Produced by the Wapak Hollow Ware Co., these skillets are renowned for their distinctive logo that showcases a Native American chief, complete with feathered headdress detailing. (We have to admit, the logo does look striking.) Their unique branding and limited production make them sought-after by collectors. With prices ranging from around $200 to over $1,200, it’s easy to see why they hold such appeal among enthusiasts of vintage cookware.
3. Griswold No. 2 Skillet (1890s-1900s)
Produced by Griswold, this cast iron is prized for its craftsmanship, coupled with the brand’s prestigious reputation. The pan is considered exceptionally rare, and features an “ERIE” spider logo etched onto the bottom of the pan (a nod to its origin in Erie, Pennsylvania). With fewer than 100 known to exist, collectors will scramble to own this unique piece of culinary history.
4. Griswold No. 13 Skillet (1940s)
This later version of Griswold’s No. 13 skillet from the 1940s is also considered quite valuable. In 2020, one of the skillets from this era sold for a record-breaking $20,000 at auction. But if you don’t have $20k laying around, you can still snag one online for around 200 bucks.
5. Lodge Blacklock Skillet
Named after Lodge’s original foundry, this Blacklock series is valued for the company’s longstanding heritage in promoting American-made products and craftsmanship. These skillets, which feature a heat ring and raised lettering, are valued for their historical significance and craftsmanship. Prices range from around $85 to $250.
6. Favorite Piqua Ware No. 11 Skillet
Manufactured by the Favorite Stove and Range Co., this skillet stands out for its adorable logo that resembles a smiley face. Its rarity and unique design contribute to its value, with single pieces in good condition selling for over $700.
7. Martin Stove & Range No. 12 Skillet
Thanks to its robust design and smooth cooking surface, this No. 12 skillet is a standout piece among collectors of vintage cookware, with pieces in good condition listed for around $350 or more. The skillet is known for its durability and unique logo, which features the company name along with a location mark.
8. Griswold No. 4 Skillet
Though not as valuable as some of its larger counterparts, these smaller skillets — which retail for around $150 — can still be a hot commodity among collectors. Their compact size and the reputation of the Griswold brand make them sought-after for both display purposes and everyday use. (Can you imagine searing a tiny steak on this? How cute.)
9. Wagner Ware Sidney-O No. 8 Skillet
Treasured by those who value functionality with a side of history, Wagner Ware is another brand that stands out in the world of vintage cast iron. Known for its polished cooking surface and lightweight design, this No. 8 skillet is one of the company’s most popular pieces. Well-maintained pieces can list for a whopping $5,000.
10. Birmingham Stove & Range (BS&R) Century Series Skillet
Beloved for their practicality and connection to Southern cuisine, these skillets feature a smooth interior surface that make them a staple in kitchens across the world. Their relatively limited production during the 19th century makes them especially appealing to collectors. Prices for these skillets can list for at least $200, depending on the size and condition.
11. Wagner Sydney No. 13 Skillet
Another rare Wagner skillet, the No. 13’s large size makes it a sought-after piece for collectors. In 2023, one sold for $950 at auction. Let’s hope it’s owner put it to good use!
Interested in more vintage kitchenware?
Find out if you have some valuable items at home by looking through 15 Vintage Kitchen Items Every Collector Wants, along with 12 Valuable Vintage Pyrex Bowls. More of a barware collector? Take a look at 7 Types of Vintage Barware That Could Be Hiding in Your Cabinet.
The post 11 Valuable Cast Iron Skillets That Might Be in Your Kitchen appeared first on Wealth Gang.
